Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Travis Etienne vs Tetairoa McMillan

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 20, 2026

ADP 41
Travis Etienne
RB · NO · RB19
ADP 35.3
Tetairoa McMillan
WR · CAR · WR15
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
56% would rather draft McMillan over Etienne
44%Etienne
56%McMillan
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Travis Etienne or Tetairoa McMillan?

Last season — 2025, per game

EtienneRB10 finish
2025
McMillanWR15 finish
13.9Fantasy pts10.4
17Games17
15.3Carries0.0
65Rush yds0
4.3Yds/carry0.0
3.1Targets7.2
2.1Rec4.1
17Rec yds60
0.8TD0.4
Full game log & past seasons
Travis Etienne
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
CAR
17.1
RB6
16
143
0
3
3
13
0
2
CIN
15.9
RB12
14
71
0
3
2
18
1
3
HOU
11.6
RB18
16
56
1
2
0
0
0
4
SF
19.0
RB12
19
124
1
2
1
1
0
5
KC
7.3
RB30
12
49
0
4
3
9
0
6
SEA
7.5
RB22
12
27
0
5
4
28
0
7
LAR
6.0
RB32
8
44
0
3
1
11
0
8
BYE
9
LV
14.0
RB10
22
84
0
5
5
31
0
10
HOU
14.7
RB11
16
58
1
4
2
19
0
11
LAC
19.3
RB6
19
73
2
2
0
0
0
12
ARI
19.1
RB7
15
86
0
4
3
30
1
13
TEN
4.6
RB48
12
28
0
1
1
13
0
14
IND
20.7
RB4
20
74
2
1
1
8
0
15
NYJ
30.0
RB2
12
32
0
4
3
73
3
16
DEN
14.6
RB19
16
50
0
5
4
16
1
17
IND
10.2
RB21
17
76
0
3
2
16
0
18
TEN
4.3
RB49
14
32
0
1
1
6
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
MIA
10.9
RB28
12
44
1
3
2
15
0
2
CLE
13.3
RB20
13
52
1
4
3
6
0
3
BUF
10.5
RB21
11
68
0
6
4
17
0
4
HOU
6.5
RB39
11
50
0
2
1
10
0
5
IND
9.0
RB29
6
17
0
7
6
43
0
6
CHI
-0.1
RB84
3
-1
0
1
0
0
0
7
8
BYE
9
PHI
4.0
RB46
3
24
0
3
2
6
0
10
MIN
4.8
RB40
11
44
0
1
1
-1
0
11
DET
4.8
RB35
12
27
0
3
3
6
0
12
13
HOU
7.3
RB36
13
46
0
3
3
12
0
14
TEN
9.0
RB28
4
20
0
4
4
50
0
15
NYJ
10.5
RB22
14
65
0
5
4
20
0
16
LV
4.7
RB45
9
22
0
3
2
15
0
17
TEN
8.0
RB28
15
49
0
2
1
26
0
18
IND
7.5
RB34
13
31
0
5
3
29
0
Tetairoa McMillan
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
JAX
9.3
WR31
9
5
68
0
2
ARI
13.0
WR27
10
6
100
0
3
ATL
6.3
WR46
8
3
48
0
4
NE
8.2
WR36
8
4
62
0
5
MIA
10.3
WR28
8
6
73
0
6
DAL
16.4
WR12
5
3
29
2
7
NYJ
4.8
WR57
5
3
33
0
8
BUF
13.4
WR14
10
7
99
0
9
GB
6.6
WR49
6
4
46
0
10
NO
8.5
WR33
8
5
60
0
11
ATL
29.0
WR1
12
8
130
2
12
SF
10.5
WR27
7
2
35
1
13
LAR
10.8
WR23
2
1
43
1
14
15
NO
3.5
WR73
4
2
25
0
16
TB
16.3
WR13
10
6
73
1
17
SEA
1.0
WR109
4
1
5
0
18
TB
8.5
WR24
6
4
85
0

Latest takes

Travis Etienne
  • Travis Etienne Jr. is gone, and the lead role on one of the league’s most potent offenses is open.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 19
  • He signed a massive deal with the Saints this offseason after rushing 260 times for 1,107 yards and seven touchdowns last season, while also catching 36 passes for 292 yards and six more scores. Etienne will get plenty of action in the passing game and will be the team’s undisputed No. 1 RB.

  • I was excited about Travis Etienne when he signed with the Saints this offseason, but over time, I’ve become less enthused. First, New Orleans worked out a deal to keep beloved franchise star Alvin Kamara, which makes Etienne less attractive this coming season.

See 12 more
  • 9 | Diff: +2 With Travis Etienne gone, Bhayshul Tuten will compete with Chris Rodriguez to be the lead back for the Jaguars in 2026.

  • In the end, Andy chose Travis Etienne , adding his second RB of the draft.

    Kurt Mullen· Jul 29
  • Biggest Differences in ADP vs Fantasy Finish RB 2025 ADP 2025 Finish Differential Javonte Williams 41 11 30 Travis Etienne Jr .

  • While the additions of Travis Etienne and rookie Jordyn Tyson are cause to question Olave’s target share, what about his previous injuries? How do five documented concussions shape the future outlook for Olave?

  • He lands with New Orleans after a season where he was 11th in snap share, 13th in opportunity share, tenth in weighted opportunities, and fifth in red zone touches. Etienne soaked up 296 touches, producing 1,399 total yards.

  • Etienne Jr.'s momentum skyrocketed with the rest of the Jaguars team after the Week 8 bye. He averaged 17.5 fantasy points per game and scored more than six receiving touchdowns on fewer than 40 receptions. Etienne Jr. will bring life back to this running game and could be the perfect complement if Shough can continue his hot streak.

  • Travis Etienne Jr. bounced back in a big way last season, amassing 1,100 rushing yards and seven rushing touchdowns for the Jaguars. He's headed into arguably an even better situation in New Orleans, at least in terms of backfield competition. Etienne posted an RB10 overall finish in 2025 with a 65.1% snap share. If that climbs up closer to the 75% range in New Orleans (which feels realistic given the depth chart), I don't see why he can't hit 1,500 rushing yards.

    Jim Moorman· Jul 6
  • The Saints signed Travis Etienne to headline their backfield, but among 43 running backs with at least 150 touches last season, Etienne was 27th in yards per carry (4.3) and 33rd in percentage of rushes that went for zero or negative yards.

  • Etienne is too good a talent for the Saints to put him in a legitimate time share of any kind. Kellen Moore's offense has been capable of producing big fantasy numbers for running backs as well.

  • The team spent the offseason aggressively adding offensive help around Shough. Travis Etienne, Jordyn Tyson, and Oscar Delp were all brought in to strengthen the supporting cast.

    Jon Machado· May 16
  • The Bucs in Week 15 didn't give up a lot in the way of EPA per rush, but they struggled against pass-catching running backs, and Travis Etienne and Alvin Kamara are both good options there.

    Tom Strachan· May 15
  • Pairing Tyson with Olave and free agent addition Travis Etienne Jr. would form a legitimately strong skill player group for Shough to work with, along with a quietly strong offensive line.

Tetairoa McMillan
  • Tetairoa McMillan emerged as the Panthers’ top option as a rookie, earning the 2025 NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year Award and establishing strong chemistry with Bryce Young .

  • Last season as a rookie, Tetairoa McMillan recorded a 25.4% target share, catching 70 passes on 122 targets for 1,014 yards and seven touchdowns. He finished as the WR15 in PPR leagues. Now, he’s being drafted as the WR17.

  • McMillan is currently ranked as the WR17 in expert consensus rankings (ECR), and I feel that managers are paying a premium for a player with many surrounding question marks. Last season, the chips fell nicely for McMillan to finish as a volume play, but increased competition and middling play under center have me worried about his outlook in 2026.

See 12 more
  • While I like McMillan, he is overvalued as the WR15 in ADP.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 14
  • If I missed on early wide receiver in favor of loading up at running back, I would be fine with Egbuka as my WR1 heading into the season.” – Aaron St Denis ( Fantasy Sports Advice Network ) Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR) “Few receivers in the WR13-WR30 range offer the kind of ceiling Tetairoa McMillan brings to the table.

  • Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR) Tetairoa McMillan already produced enough as a rookie to make him an obvious dynasty asset, but he remains particularly attractive because his best football may still be ahead of him

    Ryan Kirksey· Aug 6
  • ADP: +6 Tetairoa McMillan wasted no time establishing himself as Carolina’s clear-cut WR1, winning Offensive Rookie of the Year after nearly topping 1,100 receiving yards on 126 targets.

  • However, competing with Tetairoa McMillan for targets is one thing, but competing with McMillan to get a share of Bryce Young’s passing game is less tantalizing than what I’d like it to be, since Bryce’s 188 passing yards per game last year was a career high.

    Tony Martin· Jul 30
  • Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR) McMillan is coming off an Offensive Rookie of the Year season, but his outlook depends heavily on his quarterback and that quarterback’s offensive line, which is off to a rough start with two starting tackles already dealing with camp injuries.

  • Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR) | ADP: 37.7 (WR15) The Panthers should be ecstatic about pulling the trigger on Tetairoa McMillan with the eighth pick in the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft. He had a stellar rookie season.

  • Yet, according to Fantasy Points Data, he had the 11th-highest receiving yards market share (30.7%) among players with at least 30 targets last year. While I like McMillan, he is overvalued as the WR14 in ADP.

    Mike Fanelli· Jul 17
  • McMillan commanded a 23% target share for Carolina's offense, but the main problem is that Carolina doesn't want to throw the ball and instead leans heavily on its run game to move the chains on each possession. McMillan will undoubtedly lead Carolina in targets again, but that number is hard-capped.

  • McMillan was quietly a fantasy star as a rookie despite Carolina's inconsistent passing attack, finishing as the WR15, averaging 8.3 non-PPR fantasy points per game. Furthermore, he was the team's best weapon in the red zone, totaling seven receiving touchdowns, more than double the next closest Panther.

    Mike Fanelli· Jun 22
  • Tetairoa McMillan (15th in total WR points last year) is going for an average auction value less than their projection.

    Evan Hoovler· Jun 19
  • Tetairoa McMillan's consensus ADP is WR19, whereas he's the WR11 on MFL. As a rookie last season, McMillan led the Panthers in target share by a wide margin at 25.4%, though when Jalen Coker was on the field, McMillan's target share dropped to 18.5%. McMillan can volume his way to a respectable fantasy line, but his touchdown upside could be limited given the Panthers' third-hardest schedule and Bryce Young's poor performance against winning records.