Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Puka Nacua
vs Amon-Ra St. Brown

2026 · Week 5 · Half-PPR

Puka Nacua
WR · LAR
Amon-Ra St. Brown
WR · DET

The crowd’s lean

Week 5

4 Joes ranked this pair · Early results

75%25%
NacuaBrown

This week

WEEK 5

Nacua

vs BUF

Oct 12 · 8:15 PM ET

Brown

at ARI

Oct 11 · 4:25 PM ET

16.7

Projected

17.8

Projected

Half-PPR
projection

This week's comparison isn't ready yet. Check back later.

2026 season, per game

NacuaBrown
16.6Fantasy pts19.0
2Games4
10.5Targets11.5
7.0Receptions7.8
100Receiving yds76
—Touchdowns—
2025 season, per game
NacuaBrown
19.4Fantasy pts15.6
16Games17
10.4Targets10.1
8.1Receptions6.9
107Receiving yds82
0.7Touchdowns0.6
Full game log & past seasons +
Puka Nacua
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
—
9.9
WR27
9
5
74
—
2
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
4
—
23.2
WR5
12
9
125
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
HOU
18.1
WR7
11
10
130
—
2
TEN
23.6
WR6
9
8
91
—
3
PHI
17.3
WR8
15
11
112
—
4
IND
29.5
WR1
15
13
170
1
5
SF
19.5
WR7
12
10
85
1
6
BAL
3.8
WR64
3
2
28
—
7
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
8
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
NO
19.3
WR5
8
7
95
1
10
SF
14.9
WR16
6
5
64
1
11
SEA
10.8
WR18
8
7
75
—
12
TB
13.2
WR16
11
7
97
—
13
CAR
10.2
WR25
9
6
72
—
14
ARI
32.2
WR1
11
7
167
2
15
DET
23.4
WR2
11
9
181
—
16
SEA
40.5
WR1
16
12
225
2
17
ATL
13.2
WR14
10
5
47
1
18
ARI
21.0
WR3
11
10
76
1
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
DET
6.2
WR55
4
4
35
—
2
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
4
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
7
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
8
MIN
14.6
WR20
9
7
106
—
9
SEA
1.6
WR89
4
1
11
—
10
MIA
14.3
WR12
14
9
98
—
11
NE
21.8
WR6
9
7
123
1
12
PHI
16.2
WR12
13
9
117
—
13
NO
14.8
WR20
8
5
56
1
14
BUF
35.8
WR2
14
12
162
1
15
SF
14.3
WR20
8
7
97
—
16
NYJ
9.6
WR35
9
8
56
—
17
ARI
17.9
WR16
14
10
129
—
Amon-Ra St. Brown
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
—
23.7
WR4
14
10
67
2
2
—
30.7
WR4
13
9
142
2
3
—
9.9
WR35
8
4
19
1
4
—
11.5
WR29
11
8
75
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
GB
6.5
WR48
6
4
45
—
2
CHI
34.7
WR1
11
9
115
3
3
BAL
17.2
WR9
8
7
77
1
4
CLE
22.5
WR4
7
7
70
2
5
CIN
14.0
WR17
9
8
100
—
6
KC
9.2
WR29
10
9
45
—
7
TB
17.6
WR13
10
6
86
1
8
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
MIN
14.2
WR16
13
9
97
—
10
WAS
14.3
WR18
8
5
58
1
11
PHI
5.2
WR51
12
2
42
—
12
NYG
25.4
WR3
13
9
149
1
13
GB
0.0
WR112
1
—
—
—
14
DAL
12.2
WR19
9
6
92
—
15
LAR
34.9
WR1
18
13
164
2
16
PIT
7.4
WR40
9
4
54
—
17
MIN
10.8
WR27
13
8
68
—
18
CHI
19.4
WR5
15
11
139
—
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
LAR
2.8
WR77
6
3
13
—
2
TB
17.4
WR13
18
11
119
—
3
ARI
17.0
WR15
8
7
75
1
4
SEA
17.8
WR10
6
6
45
1
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
DAL
11.7
WR26
4
4
37
1
7
MIN
21.2
WR1
8
8
112
1
8
TEN
7.7
WR48
2
2
7
1
9
GB
15.1
WR15
7
7
56
1
10
HOU
15.0
WR10
8
6
60
1
11
JAX
33.2
WR1
11
11
161
2
12
IND
9.2
WR30
7
6
62
—
13
CHI
9.8
WR35
7
5
73
—
14
GB
7.8
WR38
6
5
43
—
15
BUF
30.3
WR3
18
14
193
1
16
CHI
16.0
WR14
8
6
70
1
17
SF
16.0
WR18
10
8
60
1
18
MIN
10.7
WR32
7
6
77
—

Expert takes

Puka Nacua
  • “McVay has said Nacua is not dealing with a hernia, though Erin Andrews said on FOX ( h/t Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio ) the receiver is battling a pre-hernia issue. This means Nacua is dealing with weakness in the muscle wall that is keeping internal tissue from breaking through. It is not too difficult to foresee hernia surgery in Nacua’s future, but for now, the star pass catcher is playing through injury.”

    Sam Robinson· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Broncos Fantasy Wide Receiver Preview Davante Adams Early reports this week suggest Puka Nacua will remain sidelined for at least another game , if not longer. With Nacua sidelined on Monday night, Adams dropped a hammer, catching 8 of 10 targets for 195 yards and 2 touchdowns. This was the third time in his career (with three different teams) that Adams has had 190-plus receiving yards and 2 touchdowns in a game.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 24, 2026
  • “IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect Puka Nacua – 9 targets, 5 rec Nacua seeing nine targets…what else is new? He has averaged 9.8 targets/game over his career, so this is just par for the course for him. He remains one of the best target earners in the game when he takes the field.”

    Aaron Larson· Sep 15, 2026
See 10 more
  • “Puka Nacua (+550) is the current favorite to lead the league in receiving yards for the 2026 NFL Season.”

    Curtis Hirsch· Sep 2, 2026
  • “Puka Nacua (WR – LAR) Averages 26 PPR Points Per Game The prediction: Nacua could become the first wide receiver since 2013 to average 26 PPR points per game across a full season. In his genuinely healthy games last year, excluding a stretch lost to an ankle injury, he already averaged nearly 25 points per game, and a simple touchdown redistribution, flipping his own total with a teammate’s, would have been enough to push him over that 26-point threshold. Only two wide receiver seasons since 2013 have even topped 25 points per game.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Aug 28, 2026
  • “Nacua is coming off a career-high 10 receiving touchdowns, which, until 2025, had been the only area of his game that lacked, having scored nine in the previous two seasons combined. Perhaps with an improved defense, the Rams won’t be quite as pass-heavy this year, but Sean McVay has nearly always been aggressive.”

    Tom Strachan· Aug 15, 2026
  • “Left practice on Tuesday with groin soreness Rams WR Puka Nacua , who left practice while walking with a trainer, is dealing with minor soreness in his groin, I'm told.”

    FFToday· Aug 11, 2026
  • “Perhaps with an improving defense the Rams don’t go quite as pass-heavy this year, but Sean McVay has nearly always been aggressive and while Matthew Stafford is healthy, Nacua deserves to be a top pick.”

    Tom Strachan· Aug 9, 2026
  • “Having Davante Adams and Puka Nacua has elevated his fantasy value, and the Rams are built to make one more run with Stafford under center.”

    Lawrence Iacona· Aug 5, 2026
  • “Round 1: Puka Nacua (WR – LAR) The counter-pick was Puka Nacua , ranked as the top overall wide receiver ahead of the field’s other top options. Only two players outscored him in fantasy points per game last year, and neither was one of the running backs typically drafted with the first or second overall pick.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Jul 20, 2026
  • “Nacua is coming off another incredible season, leading the league in receptions (129) for 1,715 yards (2nd) and 10 touchdowns (tied for 6th). He has averaged 7.1 receptions (2nd) and 95.3 yards per game (1st) since entering the league.”

    Rich Hribar· Jul 10, 2026
  • “Landing the league leader in catches and receiving yards at pick 1.05 is never a bad thing. With Matthew Stafford under center, Puka Nacua is set up for another monster year.”

    Kurt Blakeway· Jul 7, 2026
  • “Nacua led the league in receptions (129) and receiving yards per game (107.7) in 2025. He averaged an outrageous 3.57 yards per route run last season and has averaged 3.16 YPRR for his career.”

    Pat Fitzmaurice· Jul 6, 2026
Amon-Ra St. Brown
  • “Brown has started the season with two top-five performances and is primed to continue that streak against a gutted Jets’ defense — a defense that has held up thus far but has been untested due to matchup and weather. St. Brown will be popular but must be included in the player pool this week, particularly as a runback option in Geno Smith and Jets stacks.”

    Tera Roberts· Sep 26, 2026
  • “Brown has pulled away even further from Williams, posting a 36.6% target share in their two games.”

    Wyatt Bertolone· Sep 20, 2026
  • “Brown averaged 5.2 air yards per target, with 78.6% of his targets coming shorter than 10 yards downfield. In 2025, he averaged 7.9 air yards per target with 64.5% of his targets shorter than 10 yards downfield. Nothing else changed about his usage.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 15, 2026
See 12 more
  • “Brown got off to a quiet start Sunday afternoon, but eventually was thrust into the spotlight, with Detroit trying to fend off New Orleans from pulling a massive upset. The “Sun God” led all Lions receivers with 14 targets, securing 10 receptions for 67 yards and two touchdowns. Even though he operates so close to the LOS, ARSB is a volume-based PPR monster who has one of the highest point floors of any receiver each week.”

    Evan Tarracciano· Sep 14, 2026
  • “WR1 Amon-Ra St. Brown remains one of the league’s premier receivers, while Detroit’s offensive structure continues to create opportunities through the passing game.”

    Samwise· Aug 19, 2026
  • “I would argue that the safest player to draft is St. Brown. While he isn’t the WR1 in my redraft rankings, St. Brown is the top guy in my guillotine rankings.”

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 14, 2026
  • “St. Brown is arguably in the most stable offensive environment in the NFL. He plays 12 games indoors, and Detroit rarely takes the foot off the gas offensively.”

    Jason Kamlowsky· Aug 11, 2026
  • “St. Brown caught 117 receptions for 1,401 yards, and 11 TD’s. The wide receiver for the Lions has played at least 16 games or more in five seasons. Not only are we getting a player that can average 20 or more each week, the reliability is there as well.”

    Steve Krebs· Aug 8, 2026
  • “The Detroit Lions are an interesting case, because everyone is pretty much where they should be: Jahmyr Gibbs is a top-two pick, Amon-Ra St. Brown is a fringe first-rounder, Jameson Williams is a WR2, and Sam LaPorta is a backend TE1 (and Jared Goff goes too late).”

    Jeff Krisko· Jul 27, 2026
  • “Lions WR Amon-Ra St. Brown was voted as the fifth-best receiver in the NFL in a poll by execs and coaches around the league: “Savvy, knack for getting open, plays faster than his timed speed,” an NFL coordinator said.”

    Wyatt Grindley· Jul 19, 2026
  • “Amon-Ra St. Brown is consistently viewed as a tier above Puka Nacua, Ja'Marr Chase and Jaxon Smith-Njigba. In half-PPR formats, St. Brown has finished as the WR3 for three consecutive seasons.”

    Ellis Johnson· Jul 10, 2026
  • “St. Brown has been a paragon of consistency.”

    Pat Fitzmaurice· Jul 6, 2026
  • “Perhaps the ceiling gets capped slightly if Jameson Williams trends upwards and Sam LaPorta is healthier, but the Lions were bad last season, and the most important thing is that they might have a competent play-caller once again in Drew Petzing. The team has said they want to lean into what Jared Goff does best by using play-action passes heavily. That would be a bonus for St. Brown, who has consistently led the team in first-read target share on such plays.”

    Tom Strachan· Jun 21, 2026
  • “Amon-Ra St. Brown falling to the turn on Sleeper is one of the biggest values in early drafts. While many drafters chase youth and upside, they are overlooking one of the safest elite assets in fantasy football. St. Brown has delivered elite volume and consistency for three straight seasons, thriving on heavy target share, red-zone usage and his chemistry with Jared Goff.”

    Dennis Sosic· Jun 18, 2026
  • “St. Brown is the unquestioned alpha in the passing game, averaging 159 targets during that span. Detroit's offense has been one of the league's best over the last three seasons, and there isn't really a reason to think that will slow down.”

    Jason Kamlowsky· Jun 14, 2026

Who scores most this week?

Choose your top 3 from upcoming games.

Tap players in order to build your rankings.

Open full game ↗
Past weeks
Draft history and ADP
ADP 6.7
Puka Nacua
WR · LAR · WR2
ADP 6.7
Amon-Ra St. Brown
WR · DET · WR3
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
80.4% would rather draft Nacua over Brown
80.4%Nacua
19.6%Brown
Based on 937 comparison results