Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Mike Evans vs Jalen Hurts

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 27, 2026

ADP 61.9
Questionable
Mike Evans
WR · SF · WR27
ADP 62.3
Jalen Hurts
QB · PHI · QB5
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
52% would rather draft Evans over Hurts
52%Evans
48%Hurts
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Mike Evans or Jalen Hurts?

Last season — 2025, per game

Evans8 games
2025
Hurts16 games
8.7Fantasy pts19.1
8Games16
0Pass yds202
0.0Pass TD1.6
0.0INT0.4
0.0Carries6.6
0Rush yds26
0.0Yds/carry4.0
7.6Targets0.0
3.8Rec0.0
46Rec yds0
0.4TD0.5
Full game log & past seasons
Mike Evans
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
ATL
7.6
WR41
8
5
51
0
2
HOU
8.1
WR49
11
5
56
0
3
NYJ
11.3
WR27
8
4
33
1
4
5
6
7
DET
0.0
WR150
4
0
0
0
8
BYE
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
ATL
16.2
WR12
12
6
132
0
16
CAR
11.6
WR23
9
5
31
1
17
MIA
10.6
WR28
7
3
31
1
18
CAR
4.4
WR50
2
2
34
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
WAS
20.6
WR6
6
5
61
2
2
DET
5.7
WR46
6
3
42
0
3
DEN
2.7
WR85
3
2
17
0
4
PHI
19.4
WR6
14
8
94
1
5
ATL
20.7
WR9
7
5
62
2
6
NO
4.4
WR65
6
2
34
0
7
BAL
9.0
WR25
3
1
25
1
8
BYE
9
10
11
12
NYG
9.3
WR27
6
5
68
0
13
CAR
21.8
WR4
12
8
118
1
14
LV
8.9
WR35
5
4
69
0
15
LAC
32.4
WR2
11
9
159
2
16
DAL
9.4
WR38
8
5
69
0
17
CAR
25.7
WR5
9
8
97
2
18
NO
13.4
WR21
14
9
89
0
Jalen Hurts
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTCMPYDTDINTRuYDRuTD
1
DAL
24.3
QB8
23
19
152
0
0
62
2
2
KC
11.5
QB26
22
15
101
0
0
15
1
3
LAR
29.0
QB2
32
21
226
3
0
40
1
4
TB
19.4
QB14
24
15
130
2
0
62
0
5
DEN
19.5
QB14
38
23
280
2
0
3
0
6
NYG
21.6
QB8
33
24
283
1
1
13
1
7
MIN
24.0
QB8
23
19
326
3
0
-10
0
8
NYG
25.4
QB4
20
15
179
4
0
22
0
9
10
GB
12.0
QB19
26
15
183
1
0
27
0
11
DET
14.5
QB13
28
14
135
0
0
31
1
12
DAL
30.9
QB2
39
27
289
1
0
33
2
13
CHI
17.3
QB15
34
19
230
2
1
31
0
14
LAC
4.4
QB28
40
21
240
0
4
8
0
15
LV
22.9
QB10
15
12
175
3
0
39
0
16
WAS
19.4
QB10
30
22
185
2
0
40
0
17
BUF
8.9
QB25
27
13
110
1
0
5
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTCMPYDTDINTRuYDRuTD
1
GB
18.4
QB10
34
20
278
2
2
33
0
2
ATL
24.8
QB2
30
23
183
1
1
85
1
3
NO
11.9
QB24
38
29
311
0
1
25
0
4
TB
16.3
QB13
30
18
158
1
0
20
1
5
6
CLE
21.9
QB8
25
16
264
2
0
33
0
7
NYG
22.8
QB4
14
10
114
1
0
22
2
8
CIN
35.1
QB1
20
16
236
1
0
37
3
9
JAX
29.9
QB2
24
18
230
2
0
67
1
10
DAL
30.7
QB3
20
14
202
2
1
56
2
11
WAS
18.7
QB15
28
18
221
0
0
39
1
12
LAR
15.1
QB15
22
15
179
1
0
39
0
13
BAL
17.6
QB16
19
11
118
1
0
29
1
14
CAR
24.2
QB4
21
14
108
2
0
59
1
15
PIT
28.1
QB6
32
25
290
2
0
45
1
16
WAS
4.5
QB33
4
1
11
0
0
41
0

Latest takes

Mike Evans
  • While it would be nice to see Evans practice more often as he attempts to integrate himself into Shanahan's offense, there isn't much else to be gained by him trying to push it at this point. Evans is a good bet to miss a few games in 2026, but the receiver corps is already so thin on proven playmakers that he may push for a 25% target share when he is on the field. He needs to be treated like a WR2 due to his injury risk, but he has massive WR1 upside.

    FFToday· Aug 26
  • Furthermore, the two veterans ahead of him on the depth chart — Mike Evans and Deebo Samuel — have struggled to stay healthy over the past few years. While it was once considered a long shot, Stribling could end up being the 49ers’ best wide receiver as a rookie.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 25
  • Mike Evans (WR – TB) | Under 903 Receiving Yards & 100 Targets Preseason projections suggest that this season will once again be another in which Mike Evans falls short of 1,000 yards. His last season in a Tampa Bay uniform went as horribly as possible, following two separate injuries that caused Evans to play in only eight regular-season games.

    Steve Krebs· Aug 25
See 12 more
  • At wide receiver, the team added Mike Evans and brought back Deebo Samuel .

    Samwise· Aug 19
  • Mayfield returns fully healthy, and veteran wideout Mike Evans has departed for San Francisco, leaving Chris Godwin as Egbuka’s main competition for targets.

  • Evans is not being drafted at WR27 because he suddenly stopped winning routes. He is being discounted because he is 33, has changed teams, and is coming off the first injury-ravaged season of his career.

  • Now fully healthy without Mike Evans hoarding end zone targets, Egbuka could make his way into Round One next season.” – Michael Tomlin ( Fantasy Six Pack ) “There are so many appealing choices in this range, but I’ll go with Emeka Egbuka .

  • However, if he ends up playing 13+ games, fantasy managers will be ecstatic. Another reason I am willing to take the risk of injury with Evans is that when he plays, he should be a locked-in top-12 player on this offense each week.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 11
  • With Ricky Pearsall now missing the season with his PCL injury, it is rookie De’Zhaun Stribling and Christian Kirk behind Mike Evans

  • Mike Evans is now in San Francisco, which is important because when Evans wasn’t on the field last season, Egbuka’s target share was 28%

  • Yet, Samuel could be Brock Purdy’s top wide receiver at some point this year given Mike Evans ‘ recent injury history

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 6
  • A fully healthy Mike Evans in this Kyle Shanahan system is a lock for 70+ receptions, 1,000+ yards ( obviously ), and 8+ TDs…that baseline would have been enough to finish as the overall WR11 in 0.5 PPR scoring in 2025, and is the exact reason The Path to a WR1 Season for Mike Evans is paved with gold.

    PaulMarnie· Jul 27
  • Big Mike joins an offense with arguably the best overall RB, TE, and head coach in the entire league, and although this sounds like a recipe for disaster for a veteran recovering from a season plagued by injury, I tend to look at his move west in a similar light to all those optimistic prospectors from the mid-1800s…becuase let me tell you, Mike Evans on this 49ers team is going to be fantasy gold .

    PaulMarnie· Jul 27
  • Mike Evans has a new home with the 49ers, and he looks like a wonderful value in fantasy drafts.

  • 49ers FB Kyle Juszczyk had high hopes for new WR Mike Evans , but he was still surprised by the veteran’s ability to completely dominate practice, especially during red-zone periods. “The expectations we had for Mike were already high … he’s a Hall of Famer … and he blew us all away,” Juszczyk said, via Vic Tafur of The Athletic . “He was unguardable in practice, especially in the red zone. And he fits in so well.”

    Nate Bouda· Jul 18
Jalen Hurts
  • Jalen Hurts (QB – PHI) and Jaxson Dart (QB – NYG) both grade as negative-regression cases driven by high rushing touchdown rates, but both are heavy-volume runners whose rushing floor is the stickiest asset in fantasy. Hurts is a buy-the-dip candidate coming off his worst year, and Dart profiles as a strong QB1 at a discounted cost.

  • Goedert already has excellent rapport with quarterback Jalen Hurts , and Philadelphia should enter a much heavier, pass-heavy offense under new coordinator Sean Mannion, who brings a modern Matt LaFleur/Sean McVay/Kyle Shanahan-style offense.

  • Two early draft targets are Jayden Daniels and Jalen Hurts.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 14
See 12 more
  • Jalen Hurts is the 1st player in NFL history with a TD pass, a rushing TD & a passer rating of 115+ in 3 straight games 🤯

  • Jalen Hurts is one of the only quarterbacks outside of Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen who can produce in the passing game and explode in the rushing game. He may not be the best NFL quarterback, but he is great for fantasy.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 11
  • This puts immobile pocket passers like Jared Goff and Matthew Stafford on a more even footing with Jayden Daniels and Jalen Hurts .

  • Jalen Hurts (QB – PHI) offers access to elite quarterback play at a real discount.

  • David Montgomery, Tyler Allgeier, Jacory Croskey-Merritt, Kareem Hunt, Jalen Hurts – 8 Jordan Love is the only QB in the last decade to:

  • He is also connected to Jalen Hurts , who many doubt as a passer

  • 180.8 | WR70 While he missed eight games last season with a toe injury, Purdy was the QB6 on a points-per-game basis, averaging 19.7 fantasy points per contest, a higher average than Jalen Hurts (18.7) and Dak Prescott (18.5)

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 6
  • Of the top-10 scorers overall in 2025, only Allen, Nix, and Jalen Hurts were selected as top-10 picks.

    Rich Hribar· Aug 5
  • Jalen Hurts (QB – PHI) One of the most severely underrated quarterbacks heading into the 2026 NFL season is Jalen Hurts.

  • For Hurts to be a midrange QB1 or better, he’ll have to put up big rushing numbers, and we saw his rushing numbers decline last year. After four straight years of double-digit TD runs, with an average of 13 rushing touchdowns a season over that stretch, Hurts had eight TD runs last year. The Eagles had faithfully used the “tush push” every time they got inside the opponent’s 2-yard line in recent years.

  • At his midrange QB1 price, Hurts has to deliver significant rushing value to give you a satisfying return on investment. Because let’s face it: Hurts has been a pretty average passer. Hurts has never had a 4,000-yard passing season.

  • Jalen Hurts (QB – PHI) One analyst has been aggressively targeting Hurts this year, a name that generates little draft-day excitement, which is exactly what makes him appealing. He’s currently being drafted in the QB10-to-QB11 range in single-quarterback leagues, worse than his consensus QB6 ranking, with reports of him falling as far as QB9 or 15 spots past his listed ADP in real drafts.