Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Marvin Harrison vs Caleb Williams

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 28, 2026

ADP 73.7
Marvin Harrison
WR · ARI · WR33
ADP 75.4
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI · QB7
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
68% would rather draft Williams over Harrison
32%Harrison
68%Williams
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Marvin Harrison or Caleb Williams?

Last season — 2025, per game

Harrison12 games
2025
Williams17 games
8.9Fantasy pts19.1
12Games17
0Pass yds232
0.0Pass TD1.6
0.0INT0.4
0.0Carries4.5
0Rush yds23
0.0Yds/carry5.0
6.1Targets0.1
3.4Rec0.1
51Rec yds1
0.3TD0.2
Full game log & past seasons
Marvin Harrison
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
NO
15.6
WR10
6
5
71
1
2
CAR
3.7
WR82
5
2
27
0
3
SF
5.9
WR51
6
3
44
0
4
SEA
15.6
WR14
10
6
66
1
5
TEN
11.8
WR23
5
4
98
0
6
IND
4.2
WR58
2
2
32
0
7
GB
6.8
WR40
6
2
58
0
8
9
DAL
19.1
WR6
10
7
96
1
10
SEA
12.8
WR23
12
3
33
1
11
12
13
TB
9.9
WR27
7
6
69
0
14
BYE
15
16
ATL
1.9
WR96
3
1
14
0
17
CIN
0.0
WR154
1
0
0
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
BUF
0.9
WR105
3
1
4
0
2
LAR
27.0
WR1
8
4
130
2
3
DET
14.9
WR20
11
5
64
1
4
WAS
13.0
WR23
6
5
45
1
5
SF
4.6
WR59
7
2
36
0
6
GB
0.0
WR127
2
0
0
0
7
LAC
3.6
WR63
6
3
21
0
8
MIA
20.1
WR5
7
6
111
1
9
CHI
2.4
WR78
5
2
34
0
10
NYJ
13.9
WR13
5
5
54
1
11
12
SEA
6.2
WR51
6
3
47
0
13
MIN
14.5
WR21
12
5
60
1
14
SEA
6.9
WR44
8
4
49
0
15
NE
4.2
WR65
6
2
32
0
16
CAR
5.9
WR58
8
4
39
0
17
LAR
12.6
WR33
10
6
96
0
18
SF
14.8
WR16
6
5
63
1
Caleb Williams
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTCMPYDTDINTRuYDRuTD
1
MIN
24.2
QB9
35
21
210
1
0
58
1
2
DET
18.0
QB20
30
19
207
2
1
27
0
3
DAL
29.1
QB1
28
19
298
4
0
12
0
4
LV
12.8
QB24
37
22
212
1
1
13
0
5
6
WAS
19.9
QB10
29
17
252
1
0
-2
1
7
NO
5.7
QB27
26
15
172
0
1
-2
0
8
BAL
12.8
QB20
38
25
285
0
1
24
0
9
CIN
37.7
QB1
34
20
280
3
0
53
0
10
NYG
25.1
QB4
36
20
220
1
0
63
1
11
MIN
10.3
QB22
32
16
193
0
0
26
0
12
PIT
21.7
QB6
35
19
239
3
0
21
0
13
PHI
10.5
QB25
36
17
154
1
1
13
0
14
GB
15.9
QB16
35
19
186
2
1
15
0
15
CLE
19.0
QB15
28
17
242
2
0
13
0
16
GB
21.0
QB9
34
19
250
2
0
30
0
17
SF
23.0
QB7
42
25
330
2
0
18
0
18
DET
17.6
QB10
33
20
212
2
1
1
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTCMPYDTDINTRuYDRuTD
1
TEN
7.2
QB31
29
14
93
0
0
15
0
2
HOU
9.4
QB29
37
23
174
0
2
44
0
3
IND
19.3
QB14
52
33
363
2
2
8
0
4
LAR
11.5
QB21
23
17
157
1
0
12
0
5
CAR
23.6
QB6
29
20
304
2
0
34
0
6
JAX
29.6
QB1
29
23
226
4
1
56
0
7
BYE
8
WAS
9.9
QB28
24
10
131
0
0
47
0
9
ARI
9.2
QB28
41
22
217
0
0
5
0
10
NE
6.3
QB26
30
16
120
0
0
15
0
11
GB
16.2
QB21
31
23
231
0
0
70
0
12
MIN
26.9
QB4
47
32
340
2
0
33
0
13
DET
26.1
QB5
39
20
256
3
0
39
0
14
SF
14.1
QB18
23
17
134
2
0
27
0
15
MIN
9.9
QB23
31
18
191
1
0
3
0
16
DET
22.8
QB9
40
26
334
2
0
34
0
17
SEA
7.6
QB32
28
16
122
0
1
37
0
18
GB
10.9
QB24
29
21
148
1
0
10
0

Latest takes

Marvin Harrison
  • Round 7 & Round 8 Targets Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR – ARI) | ADP: 75.4 ( WR 31) Fantasy players have been disappointed with Marvin Harrison Jr. He averaged 10.7 PPR fantasy points per game last season, a lower average than Quentin Johnston (12.2).

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 25
  • I’m not writing off Marvin Harrison Jr. yet. Yes, he’ll compete with Trey McBride for targets, but Harrison should see a target share of 20% or better.

  • Dramatically increased competition for targets seriously caps any comeback effort for Harrison, and all reports out of camp make it sound like he is struggling with confidence issues. A WR31 ranking is a steep price to pay with so much uncertainty swirling around.

See 12 more
  • The easy knock on Wilson is that he blew up in games Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • Harrison is still just 24 and Arizona is going to have to throw the ball a lot. Jacoby Brissett is not capable of leading them to the playoffs, but he is capable of putting up solid fantasy numbers.

  • Round 10: Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR – ARI) I know Marvin Harrison Jr. ‘s stock is low after last season and some viral videos of drops during training camp, but the value here couldn’t be passed up.

  • The Cardinals are also looking to get Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • 08) – Marvin Harrison (WR, ARI) At the start of the back end of the draft, only six teams in this mock have both of their QBs.

    Kurt Mullen· Jul 29
  • Marvin Harrison Jr. in the 7-game sample before his appendectomy, heel injury and without the early-exit concussion game, was on pace for a 1,117-yard season.

  • Overvalued: Marvin Harrison Jr., Wide Receiver (WR31, Pick 66 Overall) Marvin Harrison Jr. has had one 100-yard game since week two of his rookie season, when he had the craziest first ten minutes of a game you’ll ever see (130 yards, two touchdowns), and none of them came last season. Here’s the simple fact of the matter, too: he wasn’t good last year.

    Jeff Krisko· Jul 22
  • Marvin Harrison Jr. was the counter-pick, a name whose price has fallen far enough after a disappointing rookie season that the risk is worth taking.

  • Marvin Harrison Jr. has had a rough start to his NFL career, and being on the Cardinals isn't helping. Last season, with Jacoby Brissett as his signal-caller, he was third on the team in target share behind Trey McBride and Michael Wilson, catching 21 of the 42 passes thrown by Brissett for 302 yards and two touchdowns.

  • Marvin Harrison Jr. was disappointing compared to the cost, but didn't have a bad season by any means.

  • Harrison is not the player we had hoped for when he was drafted. However, there is plenty of room for him to be a steady WR2 with WR1 potential if he cleans up his game.

    Ellis Johnson· Jun 29
  • In his first two seasons, Harrison has yet to record more than 52 yards per game. That said, his 11.6% touchdown rate is impressive.

    Ellis Johnson· Jun 29
Caleb Williams
  • Caleb Williams (QB – CHI) Last season proved that Caleb Williams could hold his own under new head coach Ben Johnson. He led Chicago to the NFC North title and a playoff win.

  • Caleb Williams (QB – CHI) Williams graded out as a mild negative-regression case, and the notes explain why the risk is real: his QB7 fantasy finish badly outran his passing, as he ranked near the bottom of the league in accuracy and catchable-target rate. His fantasy value is propped up by rushing, so if that production dips even slightly, his stock slides.

  • Another important component in Loveland’s ascent is Caleb Williams . Williams registered an off-target throw on 15.9% of his passes targeted at the rookie tight end last season. Entering his third season in the NFL and second season with Johnson, Williams appears more comfortable running the offense than a year ago.

    Curtis Hirsch· Aug 18
See 12 more
  • Caleb Williams took a big step forward in 2025 under new Bears head coach and playcaller Ben Johnson , finishing QB6 in fantasy scoring. Williams threw for a franchise-record 3,942 yards.

  • The Bears are expected to take another step offensively in the hands of Caleb Williams , opening up extra field-goal attempts for the veteran kicker. Santos projects to have close to 10 more attempts in the upcoming season, while successfully scoring over 40 extra points this season.

    Steve Krebs· Aug 16
  • Odunze could very well be the WR1 in this offense, and now with Burden sidelined with a groin injury, it will allow Rome to further establish a deeper connection with Caleb Williams .

  • Caleb Williams was once considered a “can’t-miss” quarterback prospect. After a disappointing rookie season, Caleb showed flashes of brilliance in Year 1 with Ben Johnson.

  • Caleb Williams, 2025 (+0.27) Stefon Diggs heads to D.C

  • Only four quarterbacks last season bested their overall scoring ranking compared to ADP by more than five spots: Matthew Stafford (QB23 in ADP and QB3 in overall scoring output), Trevor Lawrence (QB20 in ADP), Drake Maye (QB16), and Caleb Williams (QB15).

    Rich Hribar· Aug 5
  • I can’t say that I dislike Caleb Williams as a fantasy asset; I just don’t think that he should go a full round ahead of Dak Prescott and sixteen picks before Trevor Lawrence.

    Jeff Krisko· Jul 24
  • Williams finished last year as the QB5, averaging 1.6 passing touchdowns and 18.7 fantasy points per game. However, he was the QB7 on a points-per-game basis, averaging less than Matthew Stafford (20.6) and Brock Purdy (19.7).

    Mike Fanelli· Jul 17
  • The community is so busy mourning Moore's departure that they completely ignore the elite talent left behind in Rome Odunze, Luther Burden III and Colston Loveland. To cap it off, Williams gets a five-star schedule to exploit this season.

  • Caleb Williams is coming off a sophomore leap, finishing as the QB6 with 323.3 fantasy points. Despite that elite production, the fantasy community is treating his breakout like a fluke. Williams' value remains secure because he provides a safe floor and a high ceiling with his rushing ability and off-script playmaking.

  • Caleb Williams will capture the overall fantasy QB1 crown in 2026. Year two under offensive coordinator Ben Johnson is when this explosive system cooks all the way. With an elite arsenal featuring Rome Odunze, Luther Burden, and Colston Loveland paired with an elite rushing floor, the ceiling case writes itself.

  • Chicago needs Williams' mastery of the offense to continue to improve. Chicago is banking on Caleb Williams taking his game to the next level in 2026, and the team's ceiling increasing as a result of more overall polished quarterback play.

    Joe Gibbs· Jun 30