Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Marvin Harrison vs Carnell Tate

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Sep 5, 2026

ADP 73.3
Marvin Harrison
WR · ARI · WR32
ADP 68.6
Questionable
Carnell Tate
WR · TEN · WR30
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
52% would rather draft Tate over Harrison
48%Harrison
52%Tate
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Marvin Harrison or Carnell Tate?

Last season — 2025, per game

Harrison12 games
2025
Tate
8.9Fantasy pts0.0
12Games0
6.1Targets0.0
3.4Rec0.0
51Rec yds0
0.3TD0.0
Full game log & past seasons
Marvin Harrison
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
NO
15.6
WR10
6
5
71
1
2
CAR
3.7
WR82
5
2
27
0
3
SF
5.9
WR51
6
3
44
0
4
SEA
15.6
WR14
10
6
66
1
5
TEN
11.8
WR23
5
4
98
0
6
IND
4.2
WR58
2
2
32
0
7
GB
6.8
WR40
6
2
58
0
8
9
DAL
19.1
WR6
10
7
96
1
10
SEA
12.8
WR23
12
3
33
1
11
12
13
TB
9.9
WR27
7
6
69
0
14
BYE
15
16
ATL
1.9
WR96
3
1
14
0
17
CIN
0.0
WR154
1
0
0
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
BUF
0.9
WR105
3
1
4
0
2
LAR
27.0
WR1
8
4
130
2
3
DET
14.9
WR20
11
5
64
1
4
WAS
13.0
WR23
6
5
45
1
5
SF
4.6
WR59
7
2
36
0
6
GB
0.0
WR127
2
0
0
0
7
LAC
3.6
WR63
6
3
21
0
8
MIA
20.1
WR5
7
6
111
1
9
CHI
2.4
WR78
5
2
34
0
10
NYJ
13.9
WR13
5
5
54
1
11
12
SEA
6.2
WR51
6
3
47
0
13
MIN
14.5
WR21
12
5
60
1
14
SEA
6.9
WR44
8
4
49
0
15
NE
4.2
WR65
6
2
32
0
16
CAR
5.9
WR58
8
4
39
0
17
LAR
12.6
WR33
10
6
96
0
18
SF
14.8
WR16
6
5
63
1
Carnell Tate — rookie
College: Ohio State

No NFL stats yet · draft capital unavailable

Latest takes

Marvin Harrison
  • Dobbins , Jacory Croskey-Merritt , Chris Rodriguez WR – AJ Brown , Chris Olave , Luther Burden , Jordyn Tyson , Malik Washington TE – Tucker Kraft Andy’s Team QB – Malik Willis RB – D’Andre Swift , Jadarian Price , Bucky Irving WR – Jaxon Smith-Njigba , Justin Jefferson , Marvin Harrison Jr ., De’Zhaun Stribling , KC Concepcion , Chris Bell TE – Juwan Johnson Draft Board

    Kurt Mullen· Sep 4
  • Dobbins (RB, DEN) Jason (6.12) – Brian Thomas (WR, JAX) For an optimistic start to the sixth round from the Ballers, Andy decided to draft some hope in one of his bold predictions from the Live Show and take Marvin Harrison Jr .

    Kurt Mullen· Sep 4
  • The team is also highly motivated to involve third-year receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. more heavily following two disappointing seasons.

See 12 more
  • NO RB17 20 60 43 7 -8 44 4 Drake Maye NE QB3 27 87 44 14 8 45 4 D’Andre Swift CHI RB18 27 66 48 8 -1 46 4 Terry McLaurin WAS WR22 35 70 49 7 9 47 4 Luther Burden III CHI WR23 27 75 49 10 7 48 4 Davante Adams LAR WR24 36 69 50 7 9 49 4 Joe Burrow CIN QB4 27 85 50 14 4 50 4 Jameson Williams DET WR25 32 83 52 9 10 51 4 Bucky Irving TB RB19 33 82 53 8 -4 52 4 Tyler Warren IND TE4 22 78 54 10 -1 53 4 Cam Skattebo NYG RB20 39 77 54 7 -16 54 4 David Montgomery HOU RB21 34 70 54 7 -4 55 4 DJ Moore BUF WR26 21 92 55 12 -7 56 4 Quinshon Judkins CLE RB22 32 83 55 8 -10 57 4 Christian Watson GB WR27 40 87 56 10 7 58 4 Rome Odunze CHI WR28 43 89 59 9 4 59 4 Bhayshul Tuten JAC RB23 37 82 60 9 -1 60 4 Jadarian Price SEA RB24 35 79 60 9 -4 61 4 Jayden Daniels WAS QB5 34 100 60 14 2 62 4 Mike Evans SF WR29 35 108 60 12 4 63 4 Jalen Hurts PHI QB6 29 97 61 13 -2 64 4 Parker Washington JAC WR30 32 138 64 15 3 65 5 TreVeyon Henderson NE RB25 42 100 67 10 -6 66 5 Caleb Williams CHI QB7 36 98 68 13 6 67 5 Rhamondre Stevenson NE RB26 51 98 69 10 2 68 5 Tucker Kraft GB TE5 34 110 70 13 -3 69 5 Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR – ARI) Going as the WR31, around the 72nd overall pick, Harrison faces real target-share and first-read-percentage data favoring a teammate significantly over him last year, along with real efficiency concerns of his own, including a high drop rate.

  • Round 7 & Round 8 Targets Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR – ARI) | ADP: 75.4 ( WR 31) Fantasy players have been disappointed with Marvin Harrison Jr. He averaged 10.7 PPR fantasy points per game last season, a lower average than Quentin Johnston (12.2).

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 25
  • I’m not writing off Marvin Harrison Jr. yet. Yes, he’ll compete with Trey McBride for targets, but Harrison should see a target share of 20% or better.

  • Dramatically increased competition for targets seriously caps any comeback effort for Harrison, and all reports out of camp make it sound like he is struggling with confidence issues. A WR31 ranking is a steep price to pay with so much uncertainty swirling around.

  • The easy knock on Wilson is that he blew up in games Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • Harrison is still just 24 and Arizona is going to have to throw the ball a lot. Jacoby Brissett is not capable of leading them to the playoffs, but he is capable of putting up solid fantasy numbers.

  • Round 10: Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR – ARI) I know Marvin Harrison Jr. ‘s stock is low after last season and some viral videos of drops during training camp, but the value here couldn’t be passed up.

  • The Cardinals are also looking to get Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • 08) – Marvin Harrison (WR, ARI) At the start of the back end of the draft, only six teams in this mock have both of their QBs.

    Kurt Mullen· Jul 29
  • Marvin Harrison Jr. in the 7-game sample before his appendectomy, heel injury and without the early-exit concussion game, was on pace for a 1,117-yard season.

  • Marvin Harrison Jr. was the counter-pick, a name whose price has fallen far enough after a disappointing rookie season that the risk is worth taking.

Carnell Tate
  • Drafting Carnell Tate is a bet on talent and Cam Ward’s ability to take off in his second season with Brian Daboll calling plays.

  • ADP 1 1 Jeremiyah Love ARI RB1 21 1 1 1 0 0 2 1 Carnell Tate TEN WR1 21 2 2 2 0 0 3 1 Jordyn Tyson NO WR2 22 3 6 4 1 12 4 2 Makai Lemon PHI WR3 22 3 7 5 1 0 5 2 KC Concepcion CLE WR4 21 3 6 5 1 0 6 2 Jadarian Price SEA RB2 22 4 6 5 1 -3 7 2 Denzel Boston CLE WR5 22 5 13 9 3 0 8 3 Kenyon Sadiq NYJ TE1 21 8 14 10 2 3 9 3 De’Zhaun Stribling SF WR6 23 8 12 10 1 -1 10 3 Eli Stowers PHI TE2 23 7 13 11 2 20 11 3 Jonah Coleman DEN RB3 23 7 15 11 3 -5 12 3 Fernando Mendoza LV QB1 22 7 16 12 3 0 13 3 Omar Cooper Jr.

  • I’ve listed Makai Lemon’s name here, but I could have just as easily gone with Carnell Tate or Jordyn Tyson .

See 12 more
  • 12 | Carnell Tate | WR, Tennessee Titans You’ve got two running backs, two wide receivers, and a tight end. Naturally, your league mates are assuming you’re getting your quarterback here, right?

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 29
  • Carnell Tate (WR – TEN) Going as the WR32, around the 78th overall pick, Tate carries real, unanimous praise from national draft evaluators.

  • The first receiver selected in this year’s draft class, Carnell Tate continues a long line of highly touted receivers from Ohio State who look to make an immediate impact upon the league. While some analysts think this is a fantastic fit for an up-and-coming team loaded with offensive talent, I remain skeptical that the Titans will put everything together in 2026.

  • While Carnell Tate will see a significant workload, Robinson should lead the Titans in targets and receptions. Chris Godwin Jr. (WR – TB) | ADP: 100.8 ( WR 40) Unfortunately, Chris Godwin Jr. has struggled to stay healthy the past few seasons, missing 18 games in 2024 and 2025 due to injury.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 25
  • Ward’s rough rookie year came in a barren offense, and Tennessee overhauled it, adding Carnell Tate and Wan’Dale Robinson and, crucially, quarterback whisperer Brian Daboll, whose track record with Josh Allen , Daniel Jones , and Jaxson Dart is exactly the profile you want betting on a second-year leap. Cheap, and trending up.

  • With fourth overall pick Carnell Tate added to this offense and Cam Ward entering his second season, this team should take a step forward.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 19
  • With a stable coaching staff in place, they’ve supplied Ward with more weapons, including 2026 first-round wide receiver Carnell Tate and former Giants receiver Wan’Dale Robinson , and he has a year of working with other wide receivers like Chimere Dike and Elic Ayomanor under his belt.

  • Carnell Tate (WR – TEN) Currently the WR14 in dynasty ECR, ahead of several more established veteran names, one analyst believes this is close to as good as Tate’s value will ever be, even after ranking him as his own WR1 in this year’s rookie class.

  • Carnell Tate Egbuka also posted a top-20 all-time rookie season in targets (127)

  • Carnell Tate (WR – TEN) Carnell Tate might have been taken fourth overall in the 2026 NFL draft, but it really comes down to what you believe about quarterback Cam Ward and offensive coordinator Brian Daboll

    Ryan Kirksey· Aug 6
  • Pollard should find running room in 2026 with Carnell Tate and Wan’Dale Robinson added to the passing game, improved play from Cam Ward , and an offensive line that last year was quietly 13th-best in yards before contact per attempt.

  • Drafting Carnell Tate is a bet on talent and Cam Ward ‘s ability to take off in his second season with Brian Daboll calling plays. I want to bet on Tate as I’m in love with the talent. Tate is an amazing route runner who can separate at all three levels of the field after ranking tenth in yards per route run and fourth in receiving grade last season (per PFF).