Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Kyle Monangai vs Alec Pierce

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Sep 9, 2026

ADP 97.8
Questionable
Kyle Monangai
RB · CHI · RB37
ADP 94.6
Alec Pierce
WR · IND · WR39
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
52% would rather draft Monangai over Pierce
52%Monangai
48%Pierce
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Kyle Monangai or Alec Pierce?

Last season — 2025, per game

Monangai17 games
2025
Pierce15 games
8.1Fantasy pts10.7
17Games15
9.9Carries0.0
46Rush yds0
4.6Yds/carry0.0
1.8Targets5.6
1.1Rec3.1
10Rec yds67
0.3TD0.4
Full game log & past seasons
Kyle Monangai
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
MIN
1.6
RB61
0
0
0
1
1
11
0
2
DET
4.1
RB46
7
28
0
3
1
8
0
3
DAL
2.5
RB60
6
16
0
1
1
4
0
4
LV
1.8
RB58
4
18
0
0
0
0
0
5
6
WAS
4.9
RB37
5
19
0
1
1
25
0
7
NO
16.4
RB12
13
81
1
3
2
13
0
8
BAL
2.4
RB51
7
24
0
0
0
0
0
9
CIN
21.3
RB3
26
176
0
5
3
22
0
10
NYG
8.8
RB29
7
28
1
1
0
0
0
11
MIN
10.2
RB24
12
23
1
1
1
14
0
12
PIT
10.8
RB20
12
48
1
0
0
0
0
13
PHI
19.0
RB7
22
130
1
1
0
0
0
14
GB
8.2
RB30
14
57
0
2
1
0
0
15
CLE
3.3
RB50
11
33
0
2
0
0
0
16
GB
10.8
RB24
9
50
0
4
3
43
0
17
SF
6.2
RB34
8
38
0
4
3
9
0
18
DET
5.4
RB39
6
14
0
1
1
15
0
Alec Pierce
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
MIA
4.1
WR67
3
1
36
0
2
DEN
8.8
WR44
5
4
68
0
3
TEN
8.7
WR35
5
4
67
0
4
5
6
ARI
5.8
WR45
4
2
48
0
7
LAC
12.3
WR22
10
5
98
0
8
TEN
7.9
WR38
5
2
69
0
9
PIT
14.5
WR15
13
6
115
0
10
ATL
16.4
WR14
7
4
84
1
11
12
KC
3.1
WR66
2
1
26
0
13
HOU
15.8
WR13
5
4
78
1
14
JAX
10.5
WR22
8
5
80
0
15
SEA
2.1
WR88
1
1
16
0
16
SF
22.6
WR4
4
4
86
2
17
JAX
0.0
WR135
5
0
0
0
18
HOU
27.2
WR2
7
4
132
2
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
HOU
20.0
WR8
3
3
125
1
2
GB
14.1
WR19
7
5
56
1
3
CHI
4.9
WR64
2
1
44
0
4
PIT
1.4
WR97
2
1
9
0
5
JAX
20.9
WR8
3
3
134
1
6
TEN
0.0
WR131
4
0
0
0
7
MIA
2.5
WR73
5
2
15
0
8
HOU
1.6
WR95
4
1
11
0
9
MIN
5.6
WR51
3
3
41
0
10
BUF
16.1
WR6
7
4
81
1
11
NYJ
8.9
WR37
4
3
74
0
12
DET
4.4
WR59
4
1
39
0
13
NE
8.6
WR40
6
2
16
1
14
15
DEN
0.0
WR153
4
0
0
0
16
17
NYG
21.2
WR11
9
6
122
1
18
JAX
12.7
WR25
2
2
57
1

Latest takes

Kyle Monangai
  • PIT WR38 65 122 93 13 27 89 5 Michael Wilson ARI WR39 61 137 93 15 -2 90 5 Blake Corum LAR RB33 67 121 94 13 1 91 6 Alec Pierce IND WR40 59 140 95 17 1 92 6 George Kittle SF TE9 67 130 97 13 -4 93 6 Brock Purdy SF QB11 62 132 98 13 13 94 6 Josh Downs IND WR41 68 135 98 15 18 95 6 Chuba Hubbard CAR RB34 64 137 98 18 -9 96 6 Jaxson Dart NYG QB12 62 132 99 15 -1 97 6 Bo Nix DEN QB13 64 140 99 13 4 98 6 Stefon Diggs WAS WR42 68 229 101 27 5 99 6 RJ Harvey DEN RB35 71 140 101 16 -16 100 6 Jacory Croskey-Merritt WAS RB36 71 128 101 15 -3 101 6 Jordan Mason MIN RB37 67 145 102 18 -7 102 6 Wan’Dale Robinson TEN WR43 63 141 102 15 25 103 6 Patrick Mahomes II KC QB14 69 155 104 15 8 104 6 Travis Kelce KC TE10 66 138 104 14 -11 105 6 Jayden Reed GB WR44 68 151 105 17 5 106 6 Kenny Gainwell TB RB38 67 133 106 13 3 107 6 Jared Goff DET QB15 61 156 107 14 17 108 6 Jordan Addison MIN WR45 70 163 107 16 -1 109 6 Matthew Stafford LAR QB16 78 157 109 16 -7 110 6 Dalton Kincaid BUF TE11 76 149 109 13 -12 111 6 Makai Lemon PHI WR46 75 202 111 22 -6 112 6 Kyle Monangai CHI RB39 82 148 111 15 -16 113 6 Rachaad White WAS RB40 72 142 112 14 7 114 6 Jakobi Meyers JAC WR47 74 164 115 19 18 115 6 Isaiah Likely NYG TE12 76 206 115 20 -16 116 6 Dallas Goedert PHI TE13 84 170 118 16 3 117 6 KC Concepcion CLE WR48 78 200 118 22 5 118 6 Kyler Murray MIN QB17 97 241 118 21 11 119 6 Aaron Jones Sr.

  • Rounds 3-5 Targets D’Andre Swift ( CHI) : ADP 46.6 | RB 21 Some believe that Kyle Monangai will replace Swift as the Bears’ starting running back this season.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 31
  • Kyle Monangai (RB – CHI) While he won’t replace D’Andre Swift as Chicago’s starter, Monangai is an excellent mid-round pick. He finished his rookie year as the RB30, averaging 8.6 PPR fantasy points per game.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 27
See 12 more
  • Kyle Monangai will replace Swift as the Bears’ starting running back this season. However, there is nothing to suggest that it will happen.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 23
  • Plus, his backfield mate, Kyle Monangai , is dealing with a soft tissue injury in camp.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 19
  • 1 running back, Kyle Monangai has standalone fantasy value.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 10
  • The Bears have a two-man backfield, with RBs D’Andre Swift and Kyle Monangai sharing work.

  • Kyle Monangai might have the single most injury-contingent upside in the NFL at running back, because the dude straight up produces when he gets touches.

    Jeff Krisko· Jul 24
  • Kyle Monangai is a favorite draft target in the eighth round based on ADP.

  • Raymond is coming off a sophomore campaign with over 1,400 scrimmage yards and 15 touchdowns, filling the shoes of former teammate Kyle Monangai nicely. From an efficiency standpoint, he's been slightly better across the board than Monangai ever was at Rutgers.

    Jim Moorman· Jul 8
  • The bruiser in Ben Johnson's offense, Kyle Monangai, was a winner after Chicago didn't address the running back position in free agency or the draft. Monangai should continue to be the thunder to D'Andre Swift's lightning.

  • Kyle Monangai is one of the more interesting mid-round running back bets discussed on the show, with the appeal coming from role expansion. The analysts highlighted both the quality of the running game design and the possibility that Monangai eventually claims the most valuable rushing opportunities.

  • D'Andre Swift was widely considered to be a player Ben Johnson wouldn't want heading up his backfield a year ago, but ended up being a good value bet with a 57.8% snap share compared to Kyle Monangai's 41.3%. Swift was ultimately by far the better option, with a higher explosive run rate (5.4% vs. 4.1%), a better missed-tackle forced rate (0.17 vs. 0.10) and more yards before contact.

    Tom Strachan· Jun 16
  • Kyle Monangai (RB30) had a solid season but was far from consistent every week.

    Mike Fanelli· Jun 5
  • Kyle Monangai was framed as a deeper sleeper running back worth keeping on watch lists. The analysis focused less on immediate production and more on the possibility that his style earns trust over time.

Alec Pierce
  • This is where names like Chig Okonkwo , KC Concepcion , Stefon Diggs , Alec Pierce , Terrance Ferguson , Braelon Allen , Courtland Sutton , Bhayshul Tuten , and other late-round upside players start entering the conversation.

  • PIT WR38 65 122 93 13 27 89 5 Michael Wilson ARI WR39 61 137 93 15 -2 90 5 Blake Corum LAR RB33 67 121 94 13 1 91 6 Alec Pierce IND WR40 59 140 95 17 1 92 6 George Kittle SF TE9 67 130 97 13 -4 93 6 Brock Purdy SF QB11 62 132 98 13 13 94 6 Josh Downs IND WR41 68 135 98 15 18 95 6 Chuba Hubbard CAR RB34 64 137 98 18 -9 96 6 Jaxson Dart NYG QB12 62 132 99 15 -1 97 6 Bo Nix DEN QB13 64 140 99 13 4 98 6 Stefon Diggs WAS WR42 68 229 101 27 5 99 6 RJ Harvey DEN RB35 71 140 101 16 -16 100 6 Jacory Croskey-Merritt WAS RB36 71 128 101 15 -3 101 6 Jordan Mason MIN RB37 67 145 102 18 -7 102 6 Wan’Dale Robinson TEN WR43 63 141 102 15 25 103 6 Patrick Mahomes II KC QB14 69 155 104 15 8 104 6 Travis Kelce KC TE10 66 138 104 14 -11 105 6 Jayden Reed GB WR44 68 151 105 17 5 106 6 Kenny Gainwell TB RB38 67 133 106 13 3 107 6 Jared Goff DET QB15 61 156 107 14 17 108 6 Jordan Addison MIN WR45 70 163 107 16 -1 109 6 Matthew Stafford LAR QB16 78 157 109 16 -7 110 6 Dalton Kincaid BUF TE11 76 149 109 13 -12 111 6 Makai Lemon PHI WR46 75 202 111 22 -6 112 6 Kyle Monangai CHI RB39 82 148 111 15 -16 113 6 Rachaad White WAS RB40 72 142 112 14 7 114 6 Jakobi Meyers JAC WR47 74 164 115 19 18 115 6 Isaiah Likely NYG TE12 76 206 115 20 -16 116 6 Dallas Goedert PHI TE13 84 170 118 16 3 117 6 KC Concepcion CLE WR48 78 200 118 22 5 118 6 Kyler Murray MIN QB17 97 241 118 21 11 119 6 Aaron Jones Sr.

  • Fantasy Football Risers Alec Pierce , up nearly 11 spots. The biggest non-backfield riser.

See 12 more
  • Yes, this is signal related to Alec Pierce ‘s health, but it’s also a reflection of the Colts’ receiving depth chart.

  • Alec Pierce would continue to operate as the intermediate-to-downfield threat, with Downs soaking up targets underneath, along with tight end Tyler Warren .

  • Alec Pierce stepped up in 2025, and the Colts added Tyler Warren in the draft, providing Pittman with more target competition.

  • Alec Pierce (WR – IND) | ADP: 91.6 ( WR 37) Indianapolis signed Alec Pierce to a massive contract this offseason. Furthermore, they traded away Michael Pittman Jr. , making the former Cincinnati star the team’s new clear-cut No.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 25
  • Alec Pierce has seen his ECR slip a bit as he has been slow to recover from offseason ankle surgery. Now ranked as a seventh round target as opposed to a fifth round target, Pierce could see his ECR fall further if there is a lack of positive news regarding his recovery development leading up to Labor Day.

    Raju Byfield· Aug 23
  • , and Alec Pierce is banged up. Jones is coming back from an Achilles injury.

  • There is a clear path where both Tucker Kraft and Alec Pierce lead their team in targets and receptions if they can stay healthy.

    Kurt Blakeway· Aug 14
  • Deion Burks (WR – IND) Burks was a popular late round rookie pick this summer thanks to entering a relatively barren depth chart behind Alec Pierce and Josh Downs with the Indianapolis Colts.

    Raju Byfield· Aug 10
  • Vertical WR Alec Pierce stays - then has ankle surgery

  • Alec Pierce, Nico Collins – 3.7 How to support a QB on a rookie deal ( Drake Maye ):

  • Tyler Warren ’s rookie season and Alec Pierce ’s contract are reasons to believe that the Colts’ offense can continue to get better around Taylor, making his job much easier.

  • But what if I told you that Alec Pierce’s 2025 campaign was just his 2024 campaign, but on more targets? Pierce led the NFL in yards per reception in each of the last two seasons (22.3 in 2024, 21.3 in 2024), and his yards per target were identical .

    Jeff Krisko· Jul 28