Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Jahmyr Gibbs
vs Jonathan Taylor

2026 · Week 5 · Half-PPR

Jahmyr Gibbs
RB · DET
Jonathan Taylor
RB · IND

The crowd’s lean

Week 5

6 Joes ranked this pair · Early results

83.3%16.7%
GibbsTaylor

This week

WEEK 5

Gibbs

at ARI

Oct 11 · 4:25 PM ET

Taylor

at PIT

Oct 11 · 1:00 PM ET

21.2

Projected

16.1

Projected

Half-PPR
projection

This week's comparison isn't ready yet. Check back later.

2026 season, per game

GibbsTaylor
26.3Fantasy pts20.3
4Games4
20.0Carries21.5
88Rush yds88
4.4Yds/carry4.1
7.0Targets3.8
5.5Receptions2.5
47Receiving yds17
—Touchdowns—
GibbsTaylor
19.3Fantasy pts20.0
17Games17
14.3Carries19.0
72Rush yds93
5.0Yds/carry4.9
5.5Targets3.2
4.5Receptions2.7
36Receiving yds22
1.1Touchdowns1.2
Full game log & past seasons +
Jahmyr Gibbs
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
—
31.1
RB4
29
156
2
5
5
30
—
2
—
20.3
RB5
16
52
—
8
6
61
1
3
—
37.9
RB1
20
99
2
8
7
65
1
4
—
15.7
RB14
15
46
1
7
4
31
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
GB
10.0
RB25
9
19
—
10
10
31
—
2
CHI
17.9
RB9
12
94
1
3
3
10
—
3
BAL
24.4
RB3
22
67
2
6
5
32
—
4
CLE
16.7
RB15
15
91
1
2
2
6
—
5
CIN
15.7
RB12
12
54
—
2
2
33
1
6
KC
7.0
RB26
17
65
—
2
1
—
—
7
TB
35.3
RB2
17
136
2
3
3
82
—
8
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
MIN
4.3
RB40
9
25
—
3
3
3
—
10
WAS
36.7
RB3
15
142
2
4
3
30
1
11
PHI
17.1
RB12
12
39
—
8
5
107
—
12
NYG
49.9
RB1
15
219
2
12
11
45
1
13
GB
10.1
RB28
20
68
—
4
3
18
—
14
DAL
33.5
RB1
12
43
3
7
7
77
—
15
LAR
7.8
RB33
13
38
—
7
4
20
—
16
PIT
17.8
RB13
7
2
—
13
10
66
1
17
MIN
5.4
RB37
17
41
—
3
2
23
—
18
CHI
18.8
RB4
19
80
—
5
3
33
1
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
LAR
15.4
RB16
11
40
1
6
4
34
—
2
TB
14.1
RB16
13
84
—
7
7
22
—
3
ARI
16.3
RB13
16
83
—
—
—
20
1
4
SEA
19.8
RB9
14
78
2
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
DAL
10.6
RB22
12
63
—
5
3
28
—
7
MIN
30.0
RB1
15
116
2
4
4
44
—
8
TEN
19.8
RB9
11
127
1
1
1
6
—
9
GB
14.1
RB17
11
65
1
2
1
11
—
10
HOU
11.8
RB17
19
71
—
3
2
37
—
11
JAX
18.8
RB6
11
69
1
1
1
54
—
12
IND
23.4
RB4
21
90
2
3
3
9
—
13
CHI
9.4
RB26
9
87
—
4
2
17
—
14
GB
16.3
RB12
15
43
—
6
6
30
1
15
BUF
25.9
RB2
8
31
1
7
5
83
1
16
CHI
23.4
RB7
23
109
1
5
4
45
—
17
SF
24.3
RB2
18
117
1
4
4
46
—
18
MIN
43.5
RB1
23
139
3
5
5
31
1
Jonathan Taylor
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
—
23.6
RB8
19
98
2
4
3
23
—
2
—
27.2
RB1
24
92
2
4
4
40
—
3
—
8.2
RB28
23
68
—
3
2
4
—
4
—
22.2
RB9
20
95
2
4
1
2
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
MIA
11.3
RB22
18
71
—
3
3
27
—
2
DEN
28.5
RB1
25
165
—
2
2
50
1
3
TEN
31.3
RB1
17
102
3
4
3
16
—
4
LAR
12.1
RB22
17
76
—
5
5
20
—
5
LV
30.1
RB2
17
66
3
4
3
20
—
6
ARI
21.7
RB7
21
123
1
4
4
14
—
7
LAC
32.7
RB3
16
94
3
3
3
38
—
8
TEN
36.4
RB1
12
153
2
2
2
21
1
9
PIT
6.7
RB30
14
45
—
2
2
12
—
10
ATL
48.1
RB1
32
244
3
3
3
42
—
11
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
12
KC
7.6
RB26
16
58
—
3
2
8
—
13
HOU
13.6
RB19
21
85
—
5
3
36
—
14
JAX
11.4
RB20
21
74
1
—
—
—
—
15
SEA
11.6
RB21
25
87
—
4
3
14
—
16
SF
15.4
RB18
16
46
1
3
3
33
—
17
JAX
15.9
RB13
21
70
1
6
3
14
—
18
HOU
4.9
RB48
14
26
—
2
2
13
—
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
HOU
10.8
RB29
16
48
1
—
—
—
—
2
GB
14.5
RB14
12
103
—
4
2
32
—
3
CHI
26.0
RB4
23
110
2
2
1
25
—
4
PIT
18.3
RB13
21
88
1
4
3
20
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
7
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
8
HOU
18.2
RB11
20
105
1
1
1
12
—
9
MIN
7.4
RB35
13
48
—
5
3
11
—
10
BUF
13.2
RB15
21
114
—
4
2
8
—
11
NYJ
6.5
RB28
24
57
—
2
1
3
—
12
DET
3.5
RB35
11
35
—
—
—
—
—
13
NE
16.8
RB13
25
96
—
1
1
7
1
14
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
15
DEN
9.6
RB25
22
107
—
2
1
4
—
16
TEN
39.8
RB1
29
218
3
—
—
—
—
17
NYG
26.6
RB1
32
125
2
4
2
11
—
18
JAX
24.5
RB5
34
177
1
2
1
3
—

Expert takes

Jahmyr Gibbs
  • “Favorite Leverage: Goff/Jameson/LaPorta without Gibbs is my favorite leverage build, betting on DET’s TDs landing differently rather than betting against the offense.”

    Chris Cash· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Jahmyr Gibbs is expensive, but he’s worth the price given his heavy usage in Detroit’s offense. The Lions continue to lean on Gibbs as both a runner and receiver, giving him one of the highest ceilings on this slate. Now Gibbs faces the Cardinals in a game with a projected total of 54.5 points, making it one of the week’s highest-scoring environments .”

    Frank Ammirante· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Core Studs Jahmyr Gibbs is projected as the RB1 with the RB1 value score in DFS this week. His workload has been obscene this year, with 45 rush attempts, 12 targets and 11 receptions. Gibbs has turned his bell-cow usage into 104 rushing yards per game, 45.5 receiving yards per game, three touchdowns (two rushing and one receiving), 30.45 DraftKings points per game, 27.88 expected DraftKings points per game, 26.20 FanDuel points per game and 25.4 expected FanDuel points per game.”

    Josh Shepardson· Sep 24, 2026
See 10 more
  • “Gibbs is on pace to clear that line with room to spare. Two-week paces rarely hold, and Detroit could ease off. Right now, though, the Lions keep ordering rounds.”

    Jon Machado· Sep 23, 2026
  • “Jahmyr Gibbs played an 83% snap share (54 of 65 snaps), 16 carries for 52 yards (0 TD), 8 official targets (9 true)/6 rec/61 yds/1 TD, 0 fumbles. 22 official touches (23 true), 113 official total yards. First-half usage: 8 carries for 47 yards, 4 targets/4 catches/40 yds/1 TD — 12 touches, 87 yards and the game’s first Detroit score, in the first half alone, even while Detroit trailed 0-21 for most of it. Second half: 8 carries for just 5 yards, but 4 more targets, 2 catches/21 yards.”

    Andrew Erickson· Sep 22, 2026
  • “Those offensive line injuries are another variable, but Gibbs is a front-end RB1 option who will sit as the RB1 in ranks again in a game that could be the highest-scoring of the week. This is a game where you play all the core pieces on both sides, no questions asked. Even if Detroit runs the ball less as a road underdog, Gibbs has an out as a pass catcher.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 15, 2026
  • “Lions In the first game without RB David Montgomery , Lions RB Jahmyr Gibbs had 34 total touches for 186 scrimmage yards and two touchdowns in the team’s win over the Saints. Lions HC Dan Campbell admitted using Gibbs that much isn’t ideal, but he wants to do whatever it takes to win. Campbell also feels Gibbs’ elite conditioning allows this, though he was clear they will monitor his health.”

    Logan Ulrich· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Gibbs is the team’s unquestioned bell cow, but if it wants more established depth at the position, it could dip into free agency. The Lions held a late-August visit with Kareem Hunt , Pacheco’s former teammate in Kansas City, though it is unclear if he is still on their radar.”

    Connor Byrne· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Stop me if you’ve heard this one before – Jahmyr Gibbs is really, really good. The top selection in fantasy this year, Gibbs rushed for 156 yards and two touchdowns on 29 carries, also bringing in five receptions for 30 yards as a receiver. An increased workload occurred due to this game heading into overtime, but head coach Dan Campbell seems confident that Gibbs can shoulder this many touches as necessary, though it isn’t ideal.”

    Evan Tarracciano· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Ownership Notes Quarterback Jared Goff 11.7%: Detroit carries one of the highest team totals, but Gibbs can steal the TDs.”

    Chris Cash· Sep 12, 2026
  • “In the 25 career games in which Gibbs has played 60% or more of the team snaps, he has averaged 20.3 PPR points per game.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 12, 2026
  • “However, the touchdowns could run exclusively through Gibbs. He’s finally freed from the clutches of a committee with David Montgomery leaving town, and Detroit has one of the highest totals on the slate. While I wouldn’t be overweight on Gibbs this week, he does need to be included in your player pool for the pure slate-breaking potential that would leave your lineups null and void if you don’t have any shares.”

    Tera Roberts· Sep 12, 2026
  • “For example, Jahmyr Gibbs finished last season with 328.4 total fantasy points , which should tell you just about everything you need to know about the kind of production he is capable of bringing to your team.”

    Brooke Morgan· Sep 4, 2026
Jonathan Taylor
  • “In 17 games with Pierce since 2025, Taylor has recorded 96.1 rushing yards per game, 4.9 yards per carry and 20.58 half-PPR points per game. In four games without him, Taylor has averaged 76.3 rushing yards per game, 4.0 yards per carry and 18.15 half-PPR points per game. Taylor is also game-script sensitive, making Jones’ lousy play alarming.”

    Josh Shepardson· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Meanwhile, Taylor is an elite running back who will get you 20 PPR fantasy points most weeks, while Watson has quietly been one of the better wide receivers over the first month of the season.”

    Mike Fanelli· Oct 6, 2026
  • “Taylor has a league-high 91.5% of his backfield touches, accounting for 20-plus touches in every game. I also expect the Colts' passing game to be better here, opening things up and creating more scoring chances than last week. Washington RBs Jacory Croskey-Merritt led the backfield 58.5% of the snaps on Sunday, handling 20 touches for 43 yards. 19 of those touches were runs.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 30, 2026
See 10 more
  • ““ Jonathan Taylor ranks inside the top 40 of the FantasyPros half-PPR flex rankings but faces a difficult matchup against the Texans’ stout run defense. Houston has limited opposing backs effectively through two games, which could keep Taylor’s yardage and touchdown chances in check. Even with his usual workload, the low matchup rating suggests a higher risk of a muted outing than his ranking implies.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Sep 24, 2026
  • “Last season, Jonathan Taylor averaged 31.5 PPG in Colts wins and 12.4 PPG in Colts losses.”

    Ryan Steinberg· Sep 7, 2026
  • “Jonathan Taylor (RB – IND) With a caveat. Taylor was the RB4 overall, but his season was a tale of two halves.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Sep 3, 2026
  • “Jonathan Taylor (+600) is the current favorite to lead the league in rushing yards for the 2026 NFL Season.”

    Curtis Hirsch· Sep 2, 2026
  • “Jonathan Taylor was absolutely dominant for the first half of last season. Had Daniel Jones not gotten injured, Taylor most likely could have stayed effective throughout the whole season.”

    Tom Strachan· Aug 23, 2026
  • “Round 2: Jonathan Taylor (RB – IND) With Daniel Jones coming off a torn Achilles, it’s fair to assume Jonathan Taylor will continue to get a massive amount of work in the running game and as a pass-catcher.”

    Richard Janvrin· Aug 22, 2026
  • “Meanwhile, Jonathan Taylor is the focal point of the offense, totaling 323 rushing attempts and 55 targets last season, setting a career high in targets.”

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 12, 2026
  • “$39M guaranteed The #Colts and star RB Jonathan Taylor have agreed to terms on a big-time 2-year, $44M extension, per me and @AdamSchefter”

    FFToday· Aug 6, 2026
  • “Taylor is heading into a contract year, likely his last massive one, after turning 27 this offseason. He’ll be motivated, have his quarterback returning, who might need to lean on the run game more, and once again has virtually no competition for touches. There’s a very real world where Taylor is a top-two back this season.”

    Tom Strachan· Jul 27, 2026
  • “Yes, Jonathan Taylor is the bellcow for Indy, and I don’t see that changing, but the RB2 spot is up for grabs in Indy.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Jul 22, 2026

Who scores most this week?

Choose your top 3 from upcoming games.

Tap players in order to build your rankings.

Open full game ↗
Past weeks
Draft history and ADP
ADP 1.9
Jahmyr Gibbs
RB · DET · RB1
ADP 5.7
Jonathan Taylor
RB · IND · RB4
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
93.4% would rather draft Gibbs over Taylor
93.4%Gibbs
6.6%Taylor
Based on 874 comparison results