Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

D'Andre Swift vs Bucky Irving

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Sep 2, 2026

ADP 48
D'Andre Swift
RB · CHI · RB22
ADP 47.7
Bucky Irving
RB · TB · RB21
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
64% would rather draft Irving over Swift
36%Swift
64%Irving
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft D'Andre Swift or Bucky Irving?

Last season — 2025, per game

Swift16 games
2025
Irving10 games
13.2Fantasy pts12.3
16Games10
13.9Carries17.3
68Rush yds59
4.9Yds/carry3.4
3.0Targets3.5
2.1Rec3.0
19Rec yds28
0.6TD0.4
Full game log & past seasons
D'Andre Swift
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
MIN
8.0
RB28
17
53
0
5
3
12
0
2
DET
12.4
RB24
12
63
1
3
3
6
0
3
DAL
9.3
RB27
13
33
0
4
3
45
0
4
LV
14.0
RB18
14
38
1
6
4
22
0
5
6
WAS
24.5
RB6
14
108
0
3
2
67
1
7
NO
20.3
RB5
19
124
1
1
1
14
0
8
BAL
14.1
RB15
11
45
1
2
2
26
0
9
10
NYG
12.3
RB18
13
80
0
8
5
18
0
11
MIN
9.0
RB28
21
90
0
1
0
0
0
12
PIT
1.4
RB55
8
15
0
1
1
14
0
13
PHI
20.3
RB2
18
125
1
2
1
13
0
14
GB
9.7
RB25
13
63
0
4
3
19
0
15
CLE
22.1
RB7
18
98
2
1
1
-2
0
16
GB
8.0
RB34
13
58
0
2
2
12
0
17
SF
20.9
RB8
9
54
2
3
2
25
0
18
DET
5.3
RB42
10
40
0
2
1
8
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
TEN
5.0
RB41
10
30
0
1
0
0
0
2
HOU
6.2
RB37
14
18
0
5
4
24
0
3
IND
5.2
RB46
13
20
0
4
2
22
0
4
LAR
26.0
RB3
16
93
1
7
7
72
0
5
CAR
19.0
RB2
21
73
1
2
2
47
0
6
JAX
19.9
RB6
17
91
1
4
4
28
0
7
BYE
8
WAS
18.9
RB10
18
129
1
0
0
0
0
9
ARI
11.2
RB23
16
51
0
6
6
31
0
10
NE
7.0
RB30
16
59
0
1
1
6
0
11
GB
15.4
RB12
14
71
1
2
2
13
0
12
MIN
8.0
RB21
13
30
0
4
3
35
0
13
DET
8.4
RB28
11
39
0
3
2
35
0
14
SF
4.5
RB36
14
38
0
2
1
2
0
15
MIN
9.4
RB27
19
79
0
1
1
10
0
16
DET
6.8
RB37
9
20
0
3
3
33
0
17
SEA
10.1
RB17
12
53
0
5
4
28
0
18
GB
12.5
RB16
20
65
1
2
0
0
0
Bucky Irving
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
ATL
12.5
RB19
14
37
0
4
4
8
1
2
HOU
15.1
RB14
17
71
0
6
6
50
0
3
NYJ
11.9
RB17
25
66
0
4
4
33
0
4
PHI
23.0
RB9
15
63
0
5
5
102
1
5
6
7
8
9
10
BYE
11
12
13
ARI
15.1
RB14
17
61
1
2
2
20
0
14
NO
15.1
RB12
15
55
0
3
2
26
1
15
ATL
7.6
RB34
16
60
0
3
1
11
0
16
CAR
7.1
RB41
19
71
0
0
0
0
0
17
MIA
5.8
RB35
9
19
0
6
5
14
0
18
CAR
10.3
RB19
26
85
0
2
1
13
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
WAS
8.6
RB31
9
62
0
3
2
14
0
2
DET
2.2
RB62
7
22
0
0
0
0
0
3
DEN
9.9
RB24
9
70
0
3
3
14
0
4
PHI
12.0
RB22
10
49
1
2
1
6
0
5
ATL
4.6
RB43
9
44
0
2
2
12
0
6
NO
17.5
RB11
14
81
1
2
2
24
0
7
BAL
15.2
RB17
9
23
1
3
3
54
0
8
ATL
11.9
RB24
9
44
0
7
7
40
0
9
KC
4.9
RB41
7
24
0
3
3
10
0
10
SF
16.2
RB6
13
73
1
3
3
14
0
11
12
NYG
24.2
RB3
12
88
1
6
6
64
0
13
CAR
26.0
RB1
25
152
1
3
3
33
0
14
LV
2.3
RB49
4
3
0
1
1
15
0
15
LAC
12.3
RB17
15
117
0
2
2
-4
0
16
DAL
16.7
RB16
16
68
1
3
3
24
0
17
CAR
21.0
RB5
20
113
0
4
4
77
0
18
NO
15.4
RB9
19
89
1
5
2
-5
0

Latest takes

D'Andre Swift
  • Rounds 3-5 Targets D’Andre Swift ( CHI) : ADP 46.6 | RB 21 Some believe that Kyle Monangai will replace Swift as the Bears’ starting running back this season.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 31
  • ” – Shawn Gill ( Super Fantasy Bros ) “ D’Andre Swift . I’ve actually been toying with the idea of making Swift a “must-have” target.

  • D’Andre Swift (RB – CHI) “ D’Andre Swift is a smash for me at RB19. It seems undeniable that the Bears will be a top 8 offense this season with arguably one of the most balanced and explosive attacks in the league.

See 12 more
  • D’Andre Swift (RB – CHI) Some will claim that Kyle Monangai will replace Swift as the Bears’ starting running back this season. However, there is nothing to suggest that will happen.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 27
  • 5.02: D’Andre Swift (RB – CHI) Ben Johnson wants to field the highest-scoring team in league history. Rostering the lead back in the passing game in a high-powered offense aimed at those kinds of goals is a plus.

    Kurt Blakeway· Aug 25
  • Last year, Swift was the RB15 on the season. With over 1300 total yards and 10 touchdowns, he was the clear leader of this backfield.

  • Last year, Swift was the RB15, averaging 14.3 PPR fantasy points per game, a higher average than Bucky Irving (13.8) and Kenneth Walker III (11.3). More importantly, he averaged more rushing attempts (13.9 vs. 9.9) and yards per game (67.9 vs. 46.1) than Monangai last year.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 16
  • Swift should be a mid-range RB2 again this season.

  • D’Andre Swift among 55 qualified RBs with 80+ rush attempts: • 2nd in % of 5+ Yard Gains (43%) • 3rd in % of Runs Stuffed at the Line of Scrimmage (36%) • 6th in % of 10+ Yard Gains (14%) • 7th in Zone Rush Success Rate

  • D’Andre Swift is arguably the safest running back to take in the dead zone. For his entire career, Swift has always found a way to finish as an RB2 in fantasy scoring.

    Kyle Zeigler· Jul 20
  • D'Andre Swift is a favorite draft target in the fifth round based on ADP.

  • The Bears have a two-man backfield, with RBs D'Andre Swift and Kyle Monangai sharing work. But it's worth leaning into the Chicago backfield because the Bears should have one of the better offenses in the league, and Bears head coach Ben Johnson is one of the best running-game designers in the league. I would rather have D'Andre Swift than Quinshon Judkins, even though Judkins is expected to have more touches.

  • Going into this season, Swift is going to be the 1A in a duo with second-year back Kyle Monangai, as the team didn't draft any running backs nor sign anyone in free agency, leaving Swift and Monangai with the backfield all to themselves.

  • Swift racked up a career-high 1,087 yards on the ground and scored 10 total touchdowns, and with 34 receptions for 299 yards, averaged 14.3 fantasy points per game, good for RB16.

  • If that happens, Swift could easily be a top-18 running back for fantasy.

    Tom Strachan· Jun 10
Bucky Irving
  • But his competence in pass-protection as well as his chops as a receiver out of the backfield made him a valuable piece to the Buccaneers, even after they landed Bucky Irving.

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 31
  • -Wolf Trelles-Heard Bucky Irving (RB – TB) Bucky Irving had a sophomore season to forget.

  • Last year, Swift was the RB15, averaging 14.3 PPR fantasy points per game, a higher average than Bucky Irving (13.8) and Kenneth Walker III (11.3).

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 31
See 12 more
  • 01 | Bucky Irving | RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers After breaking out late in his rookie season, Bucky Irving didn’t quite live up to the hype in his abbreviated 2025 season. After missing Weeks 5-12, he tried to play through a nagging shoulder injury — one that would require surgery this past February.

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 29
  • Bucky Irving (RB – TB) | ADP: 45.8 (RB20) After finishing his rookie season as the RB13, averaging 14.4 PPR fantasy points per game, Bucky Irving regressed last year and struggled to stay healthy, missing seven contests.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 29
  • Bucky Irving (RB – TB) Following a phenomenal rookie season in 2024, Bucky Irving plummeted back to Earth last season, limping through 10 injury-laden games and finishing as the RB33. Irving was never himself, attempting to play through a lingering A/C joint sprain in his shoulder before sustaining a pedal sprain in Week 4 that sidelined him for six games. When he was on the field, the Buccaneers gave Irving plenty of work, but he couldn’t duplicate the explosiveness managers saw the year prior.

  • There has yet to be a positive report about Bucky Irving this offseason.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 21
  • Bucky Irving has dealt with a number of injuries in his short career with a foot sprain and a shoulder/ AC joint sprain last year. Rewinding to 2024, he also dealt with hip, back, toe, and hamstring issues.

  • Bucky Irving , who is returning from a foot and shoulder injury that limited him to 588 rushing yards in 2025 after a breakout rookie campaign in 2024.

  • Check out all of DBro’s top fantasy football draft picks to target >> Bucky Irving (TB) It seems as if everyone in the fantasy community is fading Bucky Irving.

  • If Bucky Irving struggles to stay healthy for the second consecutive season, Gainwell could have a career year

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 6
  • 100 | (RB35) To be clear, Bucky Irving isn’t fading away despite a down season last year

    Kyle Zeigler· Aug 6
  • It’s odd that so many people are forgetting just how good Irving was over a fairly large sample size of games over the second half of his rookie season. Buy the dip.

  • 8 | Diff: +3 Over the last two seasons, with Bucky Irving in town, Rachaad White was a more effective per-touch player, but with Irving out of the lineup last year, he proved again that he can carry the mail (although while being horribly inefficient).

  • Bucky Irving ‘s rookie season was as impressive as they come, considering his draft capital (125th overall).