Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Puka Nacua vs Jonathan Taylor

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 19, 2026

ADP 4.7
Questionable
Puka Nacua
WR · LAR · WR2
ADP 6.1
Jonathan Taylor
RB · IND · RB4
VS
The crowd's leanDiffers from all time
95.6% would rather draft Nacua over Taylor

All time: Nacua 78.3%Taylor 21.7%

95.6%Nacua
4.4%Taylor

Should you draft Puka Nacua or Jonathan Taylor?

Last season — 2025, per game

NacuaWR1 finish
2025
TaylorRB2 finish
19.4Fantasy pts20.0
16Games17
0.6Carries19.0
7Rush yds93
10.5Yds/carry4.9
10.4Targets3.2
8.1Rec2.7
107Rec yds22
0.7TD1.2
Full game log & past seasons
Puka Nacua
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
HOU
18.1
WR7
11
10
130
0
2
TEN
23.6
WR6
9
8
91
0
3
PHI
17.3
WR8
15
11
112
0
4
IND
29.5
WR1
15
13
170
1
5
SF
19.5
WR7
12
10
85
1
6
BAL
3.8
WR64
3
2
28
0
7
8
9
NO
19.3
WR5
8
7
95
1
10
SF
14.9
WR16
6
5
64
1
11
SEA
10.8
WR18
8
7
75
0
12
TB
13.2
WR16
11
7
97
0
13
CAR
10.2
WR25
9
6
72
0
14
ARI
32.2
WR1
11
7
167
2
15
DET
23.4
WR2
11
9
181
0
16
SEA
40.5
WR1
16
12
225
2
17
ATL
13.2
WR14
10
5
47
1
18
ARI
21.0
WR3
11
10
76
1
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
DET
6.2
WR55
4
4
35
0
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
MIN
14.6
WR20
9
7
106
0
9
SEA
1.6
WR89
4
1
11
0
10
MIA
14.3
WR12
14
9
98
0
11
NE
21.8
WR6
9
7
123
1
12
PHI
16.2
WR12
13
9
117
0
13
NO
14.8
WR20
8
5
56
1
14
BUF
35.8
WR2
14
12
162
1
15
SF
14.3
WR20
8
7
97
0
16
NYJ
9.6
WR35
9
8
56
0
17
ARI
17.9
WR16
14
10
129
0
Jonathan Taylor
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
MIA
11.3
RB22
18
71
0
3
3
27
0
2
DEN
28.5
RB1
25
165
0
2
2
50
1
3
TEN
31.3
RB1
17
102
3
4
3
16
0
4
LAR
12.1
RB22
17
76
0
5
5
20
0
5
LV
30.1
RB2
17
66
3
4
3
20
0
6
ARI
21.7
RB7
21
123
1
4
4
14
0
7
LAC
32.7
RB3
16
94
3
3
3
38
0
8
TEN
36.4
RB1
12
153
2
2
2
21
1
9
PIT
6.7
RB30
14
45
0
2
2
12
0
10
ATL
48.1
RB1
32
244
3
3
3
42
0
11
12
KC
7.6
RB26
16
58
0
3
2
8
0
13
HOU
13.6
RB19
21
85
0
5
3
36
0
14
JAX
11.4
RB20
21
74
1
0
0
0
0
15
SEA
11.6
RB21
25
87
0
4
3
14
0
16
SF
15.4
RB18
16
46
1
3
3
33
0
17
JAX
15.9
RB13
21
70
1
6
3
14
0
18
HOU
4.9
RB48
14
26
0
2
2
13
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
HOU
10.8
RB29
16
48
1
0
0
0
0
2
GB
14.5
RB14
12
103
0
4
2
32
0
3
CHI
26.0
RB4
23
110
2
2
1
25
0
4
PIT
18.3
RB13
21
88
1
4
3
20
0
5
6
7
8
HOU
18.2
RB11
20
105
1
1
1
12
0
9
MIN
7.4
RB35
13
48
0
5
3
11
0
10
BUF
13.2
RB15
21
114
0
4
2
8
0
11
NYJ
6.5
RB28
24
57
0
2
1
3
0
12
DET
3.5
RB35
11
35
0
0
0
0
0
13
NE
16.8
RB13
25
96
0
1
1
7
1
14
15
DEN
9.6
RB25
22
107
0
2
1
4
0
16
TEN
39.8
RB1
29
218
3
0
0
0
0
17
NYG
26.6
RB1
32
125
2
4
2
11
0
18
JAX
24.5
RB5
34
177
1
2
1
3
0

Latest takes

Puka Nacua
  • Nacua is coming off a career-high 10 receiving touchdowns, which, until 2025, had been the only area of his game that lacked, having scored nine in the previous two seasons combined. Perhaps with an improved defense, the Rams won’t be quite as pass-heavy this year, but Sean McVay has nearly always been aggressive.

    Tom Strachan· Aug 15
  • There hasn’t been a more impressive wide receiver over the past three years than Nacua. He has had at least 160 targets over a 17-game pace every season of his career.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 14
  • For example, let’s take a player like Puka Nacua, the filet mignon of dinner. When you walk into a steakhouse, your first choice is usually the massive porterhouse or the ribeye.

    Brooke Morgan· Aug 12
See 12 more
  • Left practice on Tuesday with groin soreness Rams WR Puka Nacua , who left practice while walking with a trainer, is dealing with minor soreness in his groin, I'm told.

    FFToday· Aug 12
  • He was also 5th in target share (28%), 11th in air yards share (35%), and 4th in yards per route run behind Puka Nacua , Jaxon Smith-Njigba , and Luther Burden III .

  • Fantasy Football Research & Advice Fantasy Football Expert Rankings 2026 Fantasy Football Draft Kit Fantasy Football Trade Analyzer Fantasy Football Draft Strategy: Pick 1.04 Players to Consider at 1.04 Fantasy Football Draft Pick These players will likely be available when you make your selection: Ja’Marr Chase (WR – CIN) Puka Nacua (WR – LAR) Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR – SEA) Christian McCaffrey (RB – SF) It’s fair to assume at least one of Bijan Robinson or Jahmyr Gibbs will be gone, if not both, as they’re the consensus top two picks.

    Tom Strachan· Aug 11
  • Puka Nacua (WR – LAR) could be a season-defining player if he hits his ceiling. In his healthy games last year he averaged 24.7 PPR points per game, and simply flipping the receiving touchdown gap with a teammate would have pushed that number past 26 points per game, a mark no receiver has hit in a full season dating back to 2013.

  • Perhaps with an improving defense the Rams don’t go quite as pass-heavy this year, but Sean McVay has nearly always been aggressive and while Matthew Stafford is healthy, Nacua deserves to be a top pick.

    Tom Strachan· Aug 9
  • Nacua’s 33% TPRR, 3.71 YPRR, and 0.179 1D/RR all led the NFL and Jaxon Smith-Njigba was the only receiver in the same universe. The fact that Nacua finished as the overall WR1 while running fewer routes than Troy Franklin, Andrei Iosivas , and Elic Ayomanor is astounding, and makes you wonder what he could do if the stars aligned for him to run 550-600 routes in 2026.

  • Having Davante Adams and Puka Nacua has elevated his fantasy value, and the Rams are built to make one more run with Stafford under center.

  • Among all pass catchers, McBride trailed only Puka Nacua in receptions.

  • Not in the chart but still very relevant is that in the 27 instances of guys finishing top 24 yet running under 80% of their team’s routes, we have 4 seasons of Mike McDaniel WRs, and two seasons of Puka Nacua’s insane efficiency to take into consideration.

    Tony Martin· Jul 30
  • Round 1: Puka Nacua (WR – LAR) The counter-pick was Puka Nacua , ranked as the top overall wide receiver ahead of the field’s other top options. Only two players outscored him in fantasy points per game last year, and neither was one of the running backs typically drafted with the first or second overall pick.

  • Rams WR Puka Nacua came in as the fourth-best receiver in the same poll: “Strong hands, contact balance, ability to block in the run game, run after the catch, run through the catch, can go get it, can play any spot,” an NFL coordinator said.

  • Off the field, Puka Nacua hasn’t had a great offseason, and the Rams seem to be slightly hesitant to extend him, with reports suggesting that’s not in their immediate plans despite Nacua being extension-eligible and watching Jaxon Smith-Njigba reset the market.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 18
Jonathan Taylor
  • Meanwhile, Jonathan Taylor is the focal point of the offense, totaling 323 rushing attempts and 55 targets last season, setting a career high in targets.

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 12
  • Players to Avoid at 1.04 Fantasy Football Draft Pick Jonathan Taylor (RB – IND) Another tough fade for this selection is Jonathan Taylor , who, according to teams synced to our FantasyPros tools, led all players in playoff advance rate (66.8%).

    Tom Strachan· Aug 11
  • I’ve always been a big Jonathan Taylor truther.

See 12 more
  • $39M guaranteed The #Colts and star RB Jonathan Taylor have agreed to terms on a big-time 2-year, $44M extension, per me and @AdamSchefter

    FFToday· Aug 6
  • QB Health This season, the upside cases for Jonathan Taylor and Kenneth Walker III largely depend on the health and production of their QBs, who are coming off significant lower-body injuries.

  • Top-12 Drafted RBs in 2025 RB 2025 ADP 2024 Finish 2025 Games Played Bijan Robinson RB1 RB3 17 Saquon Barkley RB2 RB13 16 Jahmyr Gibbs RB3 RB4 17 Christian McCaffrey RB4 RB1 17 Derrick Henry RB5 RB7 17 Ashton Jeanty RB6 RB12 17 Josh Jacobs RB7 RB15 15 De’Von Achane RB8 RB6 16 Jonathan Taylor RB9 RB2 17 Bucky Irving RB10 RB33 10 Chase Brown RB11 RB8 17 Kyren Williams RB12 RB9 17 2025 RB Health Last season, nine out of 12 top RBs drafted finished as an RB1, resulting in a mostly chalky season at the top for RBs.

  • Taylor is heading into a contract year, likely his last massive one, after turning 27 this offseason. He’ll be motivated, have his quarterback returning, who might need to lean on the run game more, and once again has virtually no competition for touches. There’s a very real world where Taylor is a top-two back this season.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 27
  • Jonathan Taylor (RB – IND) Jonathan Taylor was absolutely dominant for the first half of last season. Had Daniel Jones not gotten injured, Taylor most likely could have stayed effective throughout the whole season.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 25
  • Yes, Jonathan Taylor is the bellcow for Indy, and I don’t see that changing, but the RB2 spot is up for grabs in Indy.

  • Taylor was the fantasy RB4 in points per game, but from Week 12 onwards, he was the RB21, with an explosive run rate of 0.7% (41st), and he ranked 36th in yards after contact, while scoring only three rushing touchdowns.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 12
  • Colts running back Jonathan Taylor ranks second in the NFL with 626 rushing attempts since 2024, as well as a snap share over 80%. He also led the league with 323 carries and took a whopping 46% of his team's offensive touches last year. Taylor's workload has led to elite production: 3,016 yards and 29 touchdowns in the last two seasons, both top-three numbers at his position.

    Nikhil Mehta· Jul 11
  • Jonathan Taylor was averaging 25.9 points per week, Alec Pierce was finally coming alive, ending his 1000-yard season with an average 21.3 yards per reception, and it looked like Tyler Warren was all he was cracked up to be.

  • Taylor was the catalyst for the Indianapolis offense last season, turning 369 touches into 1,963 yards from scrimmage and a league-high 20 touchdowns. Taylor led the NFL in rushing attempts (323), rushing scores (18), and first downs on the ground (84). He also handled a league-high 84.4% of Indy's backfield touches.

    Rich Hribar· Jul 7
  • Jonathan Taylor's current workload is completely unsustainable. Taylor recorded a massive 327-carry workload last season, and we already know what happens when he crosses that 300-touch threshold. The last time he did it, his body broke down for the next two seasons.

    Dennis Sosic· Jul 6
  • The entire Colts offense runs through Jonathan Taylor, with DJ Giddens and incoming seventh-round rookie Seth McGowan as his backups.