Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Nico Collins vs Jonathan Taylor

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 10, 2026

ADP 18.5
Nico Collins
WR · HOU · WR9
ADP 6.4
Jonathan Taylor
RB · IND · RB4
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
92.9% would rather draft Taylor over Collins
7.1%Collins
92.9%Taylor
Based on 28 comparison results

Should you draft Nico Collins or Jonathan Taylor?

Last season — 2025, per game

CollinsWR9 finish
2025
TaylorRB2 finish
12.7Fantasy pts20.0
15Games17
0.1Carries19.0
1Rush yds93
7.5Yds/carry4.9
8.0Targets3.2
4.7Rec2.7
74Rec yds22
0.5TD1.2
Full game log & past seasons
Nico Collins
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
LAR
4.0
WR70
5
3
25
0
2
TB
12.7
WR29
9
3
52
1
3
JAX
18.4
WR5
11
8
104
1
4
TEN
9.9
WR27
6
4
79
0
5
BAL
14.0
WR16
5
4
52
1
6
7
SEA
4.7
WR59
10
4
27
0
8
BYE
9
DEN
11.0
WR28
11
7
75
0
10
JAX
19.1
WR5
15
7
136
0
11
TEN
19.7
WR4
10
9
92
1
12
BUF
7.0
WR37
3
3
55
0
13
IND
19.0
WR10
10
5
98
0
14
KC
14.1
WR14
8
4
121
0
15
ARI
22.0
WR4
4
3
85
2
16
LV
7.9
WR38
9
4
59
0
17
LAC
7.2
WR40
4
3
57
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
IND
14.7
WR14
8
6
117
0
2
CHI
23.5
WR4
10
8
135
1
3
MIN
10.6
WR36
10
4
86
0
4
JAX
27.1
WR1
15
12
151
1
5
BUF
14.8
WR16
2
2
78
1
6
7
8
BYE
9
10
11
DAL
7.4
WR46
7
4
54
0
12
TEN
17.7
WR8
9
5
92
1
13
JAX
15.9
WR15
11
8
119
0
14
15
MIA
15.7
WR19
6
4
17
2
16
KC
9.5
WR37
10
7
60
0
17
BAL
7.4
WR46
6
3
59
0
18
TEN
12.3
WR26
5
5
38
1
Jonathan Taylor
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
MIA
11.3
RB22
18
71
0
3
3
27
0
2
DEN
28.5
RB1
25
165
0
2
2
50
1
3
TEN
31.3
RB1
17
102
3
4
3
16
0
4
LAR
12.1
RB22
17
76
0
5
5
20
0
5
LV
30.1
RB2
17
66
3
4
3
20
0
6
ARI
21.7
RB7
21
123
1
4
4
14
0
7
LAC
32.7
RB3
16
94
3
3
3
38
0
8
TEN
36.4
RB1
12
153
2
2
2
21
1
9
PIT
6.7
RB30
14
45
0
2
2
12
0
10
ATL
48.1
RB1
32
244
3
3
3
42
0
11
12
KC
7.6
RB26
16
58
0
3
2
8
0
13
HOU
13.6
RB19
21
85
0
5
3
36
0
14
JAX
11.4
RB20
21
74
1
0
0
0
0
15
SEA
11.6
RB21
25
87
0
4
3
14
0
16
SF
15.4
RB18
16
46
1
3
3
33
0
17
JAX
15.9
RB13
21
70
1
6
3
14
0
18
HOU
4.9
RB48
14
26
0
2
2
13
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
HOU
10.8
RB29
16
48
1
0
0
0
0
2
GB
14.5
RB14
12
103
0
4
2
32
0
3
CHI
26.0
RB4
23
110
2
2
1
25
0
4
PIT
18.3
RB13
21
88
1
4
3
20
0
5
6
7
8
HOU
18.2
RB11
20
105
1
1
1
12
0
9
MIN
7.4
RB35
13
48
0
5
3
11
0
10
BUF
13.2
RB15
21
114
0
4
2
8
0
11
NYJ
6.5
RB28
24
57
0
2
1
3
0
12
DET
3.5
RB35
11
35
0
0
0
0
0
13
NE
16.8
RB13
25
96
0
1
1
7
1
14
15
DEN
9.6
RB25
22
107
0
2
1
4
0
16
TEN
39.8
RB1
29
218
3
0
0
0
0
17
NYG
26.6
RB1
32
125
2
4
2
11
0
18
JAX
24.5
RB5
34
177
1
2
1
3
0

Latest takes

Nico Collins
  • Alec Pierce, Nico Collins – 3.7 How to support a QB on a rookie deal ( Drake Maye ):

  • Collins was productive again in 2025, catching 71 passes for 1,117 yards and 6 touchdowns. He did take a slight dip in per-game output. After 5.3 and 5.7 receptions per game in C.J. Stroud's first two seasons, Collins averaged 4.7 catches per game in 2025.

    Rich Hribar· Jul 10
  • Nico Collins is a bona fide stud, and we are hopeful that Jayden Higgins will emerge as a startable fantasy asset this year.

    Kemper Trull· Jul 10
See 12 more
  • A healthy Nico Collins will also be a huge factor, as the connection between those two has consistently elevated Stroud's efficiency and touchdown production since coming into the league.

  • At worst, Collins profiles as a reliable fantasy WR1/WR2 hybrid with one of the strongest WR efficiency profiles in the NFL.

  • Nico Collins continued his run as Houston's unquestioned WR1 in 2025, posting his third 1,000-yard season in the last four years while finishing as a top-10 fantasy receiver once again. Despite battling injuries, Collins remained highly efficient and continued to dominate targets and red-zone usage in the Texans offense.

  • The Texans have a lot of passing game weapons, but outside of Schultz and Nico Collins, none of them are very good at all.

    Jeff Krisko· Jun 21
  • On the flip side, what if you have Nico and got a value on Jacobs (as his ADP free-falls thanks to off-field issues)? Montgomery would make more sense there for the stack-and-run back correlation.

    Chris Cash· Jun 6
  • Nico Collins' ADP is essentially one round behind his ECR in a 12-team league, with a 66% gap between his ADP and ECR that trails only Ja'Marr Chase. Although he has been "just" a back-end fantasy WR1 over the last two years, the 27-year-old is a genuine top-tier talent at the position, ranking seventh, second and fifth among qualified receivers in Pro Football Focus receiving grade over the last three seasons.

    Ted Chmyz· Jun 5
  • Nico Collins was discussed as a receiver whose combination of physical traits and offensive role keeps him firmly in the upper fantasy conversation. The analysis focused heavily on his ability to command targets while also producing explosive plays. There was a sense throughout the discussion that Collins has moved beyond simply being a breakout candidate and now belongs in the tier of receivers fantasy managers can trust weekly.

  • Collins saw a career-high 120 targets in 2025. Furthermore, he had six receiving touchdowns after totaling 15 over the previous two years.

    Mike Fanelli· May 19
  • Top cap hit: Nico Collins, $14,939,529 (4.96 percent)

    Logan Ulrich· Jul 5
  • Houston will head into training camp later this month with back-to-back Pro Bowler Nico Collins continuing to lead its receiving corps. Stroud has formed a strong connection with Collins, a 1,000-yard receiver three years in a row.

    Connor Byrne· Jul 3
  • Nico Collins has since received a raise as part of the Texans' changes to their wide receiver room.

    Sam Robinson· Jun 19
  • Coming off a rough stretch to end the year, Texans WR Nico Collins outlined the different mindset from QB C.J. Stroud. "Different guy, different dude, man on a mission," Collins said. "Man, he's ready to hunt."

Jonathan Taylor
  • Jonathan Taylor (RB – IND) Another tough fade for this selection is Jonathan Taylor, who, according to teams synced to our FantasyPros tools, led all players in advance rate to the playoffs at 66.8%. Simply drafting Jonathan Taylor gave you a two-in-three chance of making the playoffs.

    Tom Strachan· Aug 9
  • I’ve always been a big Jonathan Taylor truther.

  • $39M guaranteed The #Colts and star RB Jonathan Taylor have agreed to terms on a big-time 2-year, $44M extension, per me and @AdamSchefter

    FFToday· Aug 6
See 12 more
  • QB Health This season, the upside cases for Jonathan Taylor and Kenneth Walker III largely depend on the health and production of their QBs, who are coming off significant lower-body injuries.

  • Top-12 Drafted RBs in 2025 RB 2025 ADP 2024 Finish 2025 Games Played Bijan Robinson RB1 RB3 17 Saquon Barkley RB2 RB13 16 Jahmyr Gibbs RB3 RB4 17 Christian McCaffrey RB4 RB1 17 Derrick Henry RB5 RB7 17 Ashton Jeanty RB6 RB12 17 Josh Jacobs RB7 RB15 15 De’Von Achane RB8 RB6 16 Jonathan Taylor RB9 RB2 17 Bucky Irving RB10 RB33 10 Chase Brown RB11 RB8 17 Kyren Williams RB12 RB9 17 2025 RB Health Last season, nine out of 12 top RBs drafted finished as an RB1, resulting in a mostly chalky season at the top for RBs.

  • Taylor is heading into a contract year, likely his last massive one, after turning 27 this offseason. He’ll be motivated, have his quarterback returning, who might need to lean on the run game more, and once again has virtually no competition for touches. There’s a very real world where Taylor is a top-two back this season.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 27
  • Jonathan Taylor (RB – IND) Jonathan Taylor was absolutely dominant for the first half of last season. Had Daniel Jones not gotten injured, Taylor most likely could have stayed effective throughout the whole season.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 25
  • Yes, Jonathan Taylor is the bellcow for Indy, and I don’t see that changing, but the RB2 spot is up for grabs in Indy.

  • Taylor was the fantasy RB4 in points per game, but from Week 12 onwards, he was the RB21, with an explosive run rate of 0.7% (41st), and he ranked 36th in yards after contact, while scoring only three rushing touchdowns.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 12
  • Colts running back Jonathan Taylor ranks second in the NFL with 626 rushing attempts since 2024, as well as a snap share over 80%. He also led the league with 323 carries and took a whopping 46% of his team's offensive touches last year. Taylor's workload has led to elite production: 3,016 yards and 29 touchdowns in the last two seasons, both top-three numbers at his position.

    Nikhil Mehta· Jul 11
  • Jonathan Taylor was averaging 25.9 points per week, Alec Pierce was finally coming alive, ending his 1000-yard season with an average 21.3 yards per reception, and it looked like Tyler Warren was all he was cracked up to be.

  • Taylor was the catalyst for the Indianapolis offense last season, turning 369 touches into 1,963 yards from scrimmage and a league-high 20 touchdowns. Taylor led the NFL in rushing attempts (323), rushing scores (18), and first downs on the ground (84). He also handled a league-high 84.4% of Indy's backfield touches.

    Rich Hribar· Jul 7
  • Jonathan Taylor's current workload is completely unsustainable. Taylor recorded a massive 327-carry workload last season, and we already know what happens when he crosses that 300-touch threshold. The last time he did it, his body broke down for the next two seasons.

    Dennis Sosic· Jul 6
  • The entire Colts offense runs through Jonathan Taylor, with DJ Giddens and incoming seventh-round rookie Seth McGowan as his backups.

  • Jonathan Taylor led the NFL in snap share last season (89%) and ranked second in opportunity share (84%). Without an injury, he isn't coming off the field.

    Jeff Krisko· Jun 21