Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Nico Collins vs De'Von Achane

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 10, 2026

ADP 18.5
Nico Collins
WR · HOU · WR9
ADP 13.6
De'Von Achane
RB · MIA · RB8
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
81.6% would rather draft Achane over Collins
18.4%Collins
81.6%Achane
Based on 38 comparison results

Should you draft Nico Collins or De'Von Achane?

Last season — 2025, per game

CollinsWR9 finish
2025
AchaneRB5 finish
12.7Fantasy pts18.1
15Games16
0.1Carries14.9
1Rush yds84
7.5Yds/carry5.7
8.0Targets5.3
4.7Rec4.2
74Rec yds31
0.5TD0.8
Full game log & past seasons
Nico Collins
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
LAR
4.0
WR70
5
3
25
0
2
TB
12.7
WR29
9
3
52
1
3
JAX
18.4
WR5
11
8
104
1
4
TEN
9.9
WR27
6
4
79
0
5
BAL
14.0
WR16
5
4
52
1
6
7
SEA
4.7
WR59
10
4
27
0
8
BYE
9
DEN
11.0
WR28
11
7
75
0
10
JAX
19.1
WR5
15
7
136
0
11
TEN
19.7
WR4
10
9
92
1
12
BUF
7.0
WR37
3
3
55
0
13
IND
19.0
WR10
10
5
98
0
14
KC
14.1
WR14
8
4
121
0
15
ARI
22.0
WR4
4
3
85
2
16
LV
7.9
WR38
9
4
59
0
17
LAC
7.2
WR40
4
3
57
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
IND
14.7
WR14
8
6
117
0
2
CHI
23.5
WR4
10
8
135
1
3
MIN
10.6
WR36
10
4
86
0
4
JAX
27.1
WR1
15
12
151
1
5
BUF
14.8
WR16
2
2
78
1
6
7
8
BYE
9
10
11
DAL
7.4
WR46
7
4
54
0
12
TEN
17.7
WR8
9
5
92
1
13
JAX
15.9
WR15
11
8
119
0
14
15
MIA
15.7
WR19
6
4
17
2
16
KC
9.5
WR37
10
7
60
0
17
BAL
7.4
WR46
6
3
59
0
18
TEN
12.3
WR26
5
5
38
1
De'Von Achane
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
IND
15.0
RB10
7
55
0
4
3
20
1
2
NE
22.2
RB3
11
30
0
10
8
92
1
3
BUF
12.6
RB16
12
62
0
9
7
29
0
4
NYJ
16.6
RB16
20
99
1
2
1
2
0
5
CAR
13.6
RB16
10
16
0
7
6
30
1
6
LAC
29.0
RB5
16
128
2
6
4
22
0
7
CLE
11.3
RB16
13
82
0
5
3
16
0
8
ATL
17.6
RB9
18
67
0
7
5
24
1
9
BAL
13.6
RB11
14
67
0
10
6
39
0
10
BUF
37.5
RB2
22
174
2
6
6
51
0
11
WAS
19.0
RB8
21
120
0
5
5
45
0
12
13
NO
19.4
RB5
22
134
1
1
0
0
0
14
NYJ
17.0
RB7
7
92
1
1
1
13
0
15
PIT
15.7
RB12
12
60
0
6
6
67
0
16
CIN
16.5
RB15
15
81
1
3
3
9
0
17
TB
12.7
RB17
18
83
0
3
3
29
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
JAX
19.5
RB6
10
24
1
7
7
76
0
2
BUF
26.0
RB3
22
96
0
7
7
69
1
3
SEA
7.3
RB36
11
30
0
5
3
28
0
4
TEN
4.4
RB49
10
15
0
3
3
14
0
5
NE
2.2
RB52
3
18
0
1
1
-1
0
6
BYE
7
IND
9.5
RB26
15
77
0
3
2
8
0
8
ARI
23.7
RB3
10
97
0
8
6
50
1
9
BUF
28.1
RB2
12
63
1
8
8
58
1
10
LAR
7.7
RB28
12
37
0
5
5
15
0
11
LV
18.5
RB7
17
73
1
4
4
32
0
12
NE
19.1
RB6
10
32
0
4
3
24
2
13
GB
17.0
RB12
7
14
0
9
8
56
1
14
NYJ
15.9
RB13
14
24
1
7
6
45
0
15
HOU
11.1
RB21
12
41
0
7
7
35
0
16
SF
28.0
RB3
17
120
1
7
6
70
0
17
CLE
4.8
RB39
10
25
0
2
2
13
0
18
NYJ
18.1
RB7
11
121
1
0
0
0
0

Latest takes

Nico Collins
  • Alec Pierce, Nico Collins – 3.7 How to support a QB on a rookie deal ( Drake Maye ):

  • Collins was productive again in 2025, catching 71 passes for 1,117 yards and 6 touchdowns. He did take a slight dip in per-game output. After 5.3 and 5.7 receptions per game in C.J. Stroud's first two seasons, Collins averaged 4.7 catches per game in 2025.

    Rich Hribar· Jul 10
  • Nico Collins is a bona fide stud, and we are hopeful that Jayden Higgins will emerge as a startable fantasy asset this year.

    Kemper Trull· Jul 10
See 12 more
  • A healthy Nico Collins will also be a huge factor, as the connection between those two has consistently elevated Stroud's efficiency and touchdown production since coming into the league.

  • At worst, Collins profiles as a reliable fantasy WR1/WR2 hybrid with one of the strongest WR efficiency profiles in the NFL.

  • Nico Collins continued his run as Houston's unquestioned WR1 in 2025, posting his third 1,000-yard season in the last four years while finishing as a top-10 fantasy receiver once again. Despite battling injuries, Collins remained highly efficient and continued to dominate targets and red-zone usage in the Texans offense.

  • The Texans have a lot of passing game weapons, but outside of Schultz and Nico Collins, none of them are very good at all.

    Jeff Krisko· Jun 21
  • On the flip side, what if you have Nico and got a value on Jacobs (as his ADP free-falls thanks to off-field issues)? Montgomery would make more sense there for the stack-and-run back correlation.

    Chris Cash· Jun 6
  • Nico Collins' ADP is essentially one round behind his ECR in a 12-team league, with a 66% gap between his ADP and ECR that trails only Ja'Marr Chase. Although he has been "just" a back-end fantasy WR1 over the last two years, the 27-year-old is a genuine top-tier talent at the position, ranking seventh, second and fifth among qualified receivers in Pro Football Focus receiving grade over the last three seasons.

    Ted Chmyz· Jun 5
  • Nico Collins was discussed as a receiver whose combination of physical traits and offensive role keeps him firmly in the upper fantasy conversation. The analysis focused heavily on his ability to command targets while also producing explosive plays. There was a sense throughout the discussion that Collins has moved beyond simply being a breakout candidate and now belongs in the tier of receivers fantasy managers can trust weekly.

  • Collins saw a career-high 120 targets in 2025. Furthermore, he had six receiving touchdowns after totaling 15 over the previous two years.

    Mike Fanelli· May 19
  • Top cap hit: Nico Collins, $14,939,529 (4.96 percent)

    Logan Ulrich· Jul 5
  • Houston will head into training camp later this month with back-to-back Pro Bowler Nico Collins continuing to lead its receiving corps. Stroud has formed a strong connection with Collins, a 1,000-yard receiver three years in a row.

    Connor Byrne· Jul 3
  • Nico Collins has since received a raise as part of the Texans' changes to their wide receiver room.

    Sam Robinson· Jun 19
  • Coming off a rough stretch to end the year, Texans WR Nico Collins outlined the different mindset from QB C.J. Stroud. "Different guy, different dude, man on a mission," Collins said. "Man, he's ready to hunt."

De'Von Achane
  • De’Von Achane (MIA) — ECR: RB10 | Projection Rank: RB6 | Projected FPTS: 259.

  • But Achane will be sailing into some fierce headwinds this year. The Dolphins’ Vegas win total for 2026 was 4.5 as of this writing – and it was juiced toward the under. Miami’s offensive line is expected to be among the worst in the league.

  • There’s no denying that Achane is an abundantly talented player and a fun watch. He’s averaged 5.6 yards per carry for his career, he’s scored double-digit touchdowns in each of his first three NFL seasons, and he’s had 145 catches over the last two years. Achane finished RB5 in half-point PPR scoring last year.

See 12 more
  • This is where I tell you that I am in on De’Von Achane, their only player going inside the top-130 by average draft position. Some fear him, but his downside is baked into his cost. I have him as my RB3 and I actively recommend him.

    Jeff Krisko· Aug 3
  • Achane has had a major downgrade in team context. For one, Mike McDaniel is no longer calling plays.

  • Players such as Christian McCaffrey , Jahmyr Gibbs , Bijan Robinson and De’Von Achane all cleared 60 receptions last season. They produce in every phase of the game.

  • For those who are worried about De'Von Achane and the Miami offense struggling so much that he will not be productive, maybe just look back at 2025, when the Dolphins struggled… and he wasn't one of the most consistent RBs in fantasy; he was THE most consistent RB in fantasy. Achane can get it done on the ground and in the air, so regardless of game script, he is a blessing for most fantasy teams.

    Colt Williams· Jul 13
  • Achane is one of the best backs in the league and just got a massive payday.

    Ethan Woodie· Jul 11
  • Another pleasant surprise was having De'Von Achane fall to me. Having him fall to the second half of the second round, with his average draft position (ADP) anywhere from 10-15, is crazy.

    Kurt Blakeway· Jul 10
  • Among 43 running backs with at least 150 touches last season, De'Von Achane was second in yards per touch (6.0), sixth in scrimmage yards (1,838), and first in runs that gained 10-plus yards (16.8%).

  • It's hard, though, not to be concerned that his numbers in the receiving game could dip significantly without Tua Tagovailoa, having averaged five targets per game with him and 2.45 without him. The offense has no weapons, and if they can't move the ball and stay on the field, it could be catastrophic for Achane's value.

    Tom Strachan· Jun 30
  • Last season, De'Von Achane exceeded his previous career-high 907 rushing yards by 443 rushing yards (1,350). He surpassed 1,000 rushing yards for the first time in his career while hitting 85+ targets for the second consecutive year. It's hard, though, not to be concerned that his numbers in the receiving game could dip significantly without Tua Tagovailoa, having averaged five targets per game with him and 2.45 without him.

    Tom Strachan· Jun 28
  • Malik Willis, however, could impact Achane's targets due to his propensity to break from the pocket. This tendency will rob Achane of the checkdown volume that he enjoyed with Tua Tagoviloa under center.

  • We would be kidding ourselves if we didn't consider Achane to be the centerpiece of the Dolphins' offense and our fantasy rosters. Stacking this receiving production on top of the leader of 40+ yard rushes since 2023 feels like cheating, but because of this, he will be the highest-scoring Dolphin for fantasy this year.

  • Achane is certainly talented enough to overcome these obstacles, but the concerns around him aren't factored into his early second-round average draft position (ADP). I'm not projecting him to fall into RB3 territory, but an RB2 finish is certainly plausible, which would be a major disappointment.

    Kyle Zeigler· Jun 22