Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Jahmyr Gibbs
vs Christian McCaffrey

2026 · Week 5 · Half-PPR

Jahmyr Gibbs
RB · DET
Christian McCaffrey
RB · SF

The crowd’s lean

Week 5

1 Joe ranked this pair · Early results

100%0%
GibbsMcCaffrey

This week

WEEK 5

Gibbs

at ARI

Oct 11 · 4:25 PM ET

McCaffrey

at SEA

Oct 11 · 4:25 PM ET

21.2

Projected

14.1

Projected

Half-PPR
projection

This week's comparison isn't ready yet. Check back later.

2026 season, per game

GibbsMcCaffrey
26.3Fantasy pts16.5
4Games4
20.0Carries12.5
88Rush yds55
4.4Yds/carry4.4
7.0Targets5.5
5.5Receptions4.0
47Receiving yds31
—Touchdowns—
GibbsMcCaffrey
19.3Fantasy pts21.5
17Games17
14.3Carries18.3
72Rush yds71
5.0Yds/carry3.9
5.5Targets7.6
4.5Receptions6.0
36Receiving yds54
1.1Touchdowns1.0
Full game log & past seasons +
Jahmyr Gibbs
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
—
31.1
RB4
29
156
2
5
5
30
—
2
—
20.3
RB5
16
52
—
8
6
61
1
3
—
37.9
RB1
20
99
2
8
7
65
1
4
—
15.7
RB14
15
46
1
7
4
31
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
GB
10.0
RB25
9
19
—
10
10
31
—
2
CHI
17.9
RB9
12
94
1
3
3
10
—
3
BAL
24.4
RB3
22
67
2
6
5
32
—
4
CLE
16.7
RB15
15
91
1
2
2
6
—
5
CIN
15.7
RB12
12
54
—
2
2
33
1
6
KC
7.0
RB26
17
65
—
2
1
—
—
7
TB
35.3
RB2
17
136
2
3
3
82
—
8
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
MIN
4.3
RB40
9
25
—
3
3
3
—
10
WAS
36.7
RB3
15
142
2
4
3
30
1
11
PHI
17.1
RB12
12
39
—
8
5
107
—
12
NYG
49.9
RB1
15
219
2
12
11
45
1
13
GB
10.1
RB28
20
68
—
4
3
18
—
14
DAL
33.5
RB1
12
43
3
7
7
77
—
15
LAR
7.8
RB33
13
38
—
7
4
20
—
16
PIT
17.8
RB13
7
2
—
13
10
66
1
17
MIN
5.4
RB37
17
41
—
3
2
23
—
18
CHI
18.8
RB4
19
80
—
5
3
33
1
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
LAR
15.4
RB16
11
40
1
6
4
34
—
2
TB
14.1
RB16
13
84
—
7
7
22
—
3
ARI
16.3
RB13
16
83
—
—
—
20
1
4
SEA
19.8
RB9
14
78
2
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
DAL
10.6
RB22
12
63
—
5
3
28
—
7
MIN
30.0
RB1
15
116
2
4
4
44
—
8
TEN
19.8
RB9
11
127
1
1
1
6
—
9
GB
14.1
RB17
11
65
1
2
1
11
—
10
HOU
11.8
RB17
19
71
—
3
2
37
—
11
JAX
18.8
RB6
11
69
1
1
1
54
—
12
IND
23.4
RB4
21
90
2
3
3
9
—
13
CHI
9.4
RB26
9
87
—
4
2
17
—
14
GB
16.3
RB12
15
43
—
6
6
30
1
15
BUF
25.9
RB2
8
31
1
7
5
83
1
16
CHI
23.4
RB7
23
109
1
5
4
45
—
17
SF
24.3
RB2
18
117
1
4
4
46
—
18
MIN
43.5
RB1
23
139
3
5
5
31
1
Christian McCaffrey
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
—
11.3
RB22
10
68
—
8
5
20
—
2
—
20.6
RB3
10
23
2
4
4
43
—
3
—
19.6
RB5
15
75
1
5
4
41
—
4
—
14.5
RB19
15
52
1
5
3
18
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
SEA
18.7
RB5
22
69
—
10
9
73
—
2
NO
19.7
RB5
13
55
—
7
6
52
1
3
ARI
19.0
RB8
17
52
—
15
10
88
—
4
JAX
23.1
RB8
17
49
—
11
6
92
1
5
LAR
23.9
RB6
22
57
—
9
8
82
1
6
TB
20.6
RB9
17
54
1
8
7
57
—
7
ATL
35.6
RB1
24
129
2
8
7
72
—
8
HOU
8.3
RB28
8
25
—
6
3
43
—
9
NYG
31.8
RB1
28
106
1
6
5
67
1
10
LAR
13.6
RB16
12
30
—
10
8
66
—
11
ARI
32.6
RB2
13
81
2
6
5
40
1
12
CAR
23.7
RB3
24
89
1
7
7
53
—
13
CLE
15.4
RB12
20
53
1
4
4
21
—
14
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
15
TEN
15.2
RB14
22
73
1
1
1
14
—
16
IND
29.6
RB3
21
117
—
8
6
29
2
17
CHI
26.1
RB4
23
140
1
6
4
41
—
18
SEA
8.7
RB23
8
23
—
7
6
34
—
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
2
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
3
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
4
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
7
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
8
BYE
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
10
TB
13.7
RB11
13
39
—
7
6
68
—
11
SEA
12.6
RB16
19
79
—
5
4
27
—
12
GB
6.3
RB31
11
31
—
4
3
37
—
13
BUF
7.7
RB34
7
53
—
3
2
14
—

Expert takes

Jahmyr Gibbs
  • “Favorite Leverage: Goff/Jameson/LaPorta without Gibbs is my favorite leverage build, betting on DET’s TDs landing differently rather than betting against the offense.”

    Chris Cash· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Jahmyr Gibbs is expensive, but he’s worth the price given his heavy usage in Detroit’s offense. The Lions continue to lean on Gibbs as both a runner and receiver, giving him one of the highest ceilings on this slate. Now Gibbs faces the Cardinals in a game with a projected total of 54.5 points, making it one of the week’s highest-scoring environments .”

    Frank Ammirante· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Core Studs Jahmyr Gibbs is projected as the RB1 with the RB1 value score in DFS this week. His workload has been obscene this year, with 45 rush attempts, 12 targets and 11 receptions. Gibbs has turned his bell-cow usage into 104 rushing yards per game, 45.5 receiving yards per game, three touchdowns (two rushing and one receiving), 30.45 DraftKings points per game, 27.88 expected DraftKings points per game, 26.20 FanDuel points per game and 25.4 expected FanDuel points per game.”

    Josh Shepardson· Sep 24, 2026
See 10 more
  • “Gibbs is on pace to clear that line with room to spare. Two-week paces rarely hold, and Detroit could ease off. Right now, though, the Lions keep ordering rounds.”

    Jon Machado· Sep 23, 2026
  • “Jahmyr Gibbs played an 83% snap share (54 of 65 snaps), 16 carries for 52 yards (0 TD), 8 official targets (9 true)/6 rec/61 yds/1 TD, 0 fumbles. 22 official touches (23 true), 113 official total yards. First-half usage: 8 carries for 47 yards, 4 targets/4 catches/40 yds/1 TD — 12 touches, 87 yards and the game’s first Detroit score, in the first half alone, even while Detroit trailed 0-21 for most of it. Second half: 8 carries for just 5 yards, but 4 more targets, 2 catches/21 yards.”

    Andrew Erickson· Sep 22, 2026
  • “Those offensive line injuries are another variable, but Gibbs is a front-end RB1 option who will sit as the RB1 in ranks again in a game that could be the highest-scoring of the week. This is a game where you play all the core pieces on both sides, no questions asked. Even if Detroit runs the ball less as a road underdog, Gibbs has an out as a pass catcher.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 15, 2026
  • “Lions In the first game without RB David Montgomery , Lions RB Jahmyr Gibbs had 34 total touches for 186 scrimmage yards and two touchdowns in the team’s win over the Saints. Lions HC Dan Campbell admitted using Gibbs that much isn’t ideal, but he wants to do whatever it takes to win. Campbell also feels Gibbs’ elite conditioning allows this, though he was clear they will monitor his health.”

    Logan Ulrich· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Gibbs is the team’s unquestioned bell cow, but if it wants more established depth at the position, it could dip into free agency. The Lions held a late-August visit with Kareem Hunt , Pacheco’s former teammate in Kansas City, though it is unclear if he is still on their radar.”

    Connor Byrne· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Stop me if you’ve heard this one before – Jahmyr Gibbs is really, really good. The top selection in fantasy this year, Gibbs rushed for 156 yards and two touchdowns on 29 carries, also bringing in five receptions for 30 yards as a receiver. An increased workload occurred due to this game heading into overtime, but head coach Dan Campbell seems confident that Gibbs can shoulder this many touches as necessary, though it isn’t ideal.”

    Evan Tarracciano· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Ownership Notes Quarterback Jared Goff 11.7%: Detroit carries one of the highest team totals, but Gibbs can steal the TDs.”

    Chris Cash· Sep 12, 2026
  • “In the 25 career games in which Gibbs has played 60% or more of the team snaps, he has averaged 20.3 PPR points per game.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 12, 2026
  • “However, the touchdowns could run exclusively through Gibbs. He’s finally freed from the clutches of a committee with David Montgomery leaving town, and Detroit has one of the highest totals on the slate. While I wouldn’t be overweight on Gibbs this week, he does need to be included in your player pool for the pure slate-breaking potential that would leave your lineups null and void if you don’t have any shares.”

    Tera Roberts· Sep 12, 2026
  • “For example, Jahmyr Gibbs finished last season with 328.4 total fantasy points , which should tell you just about everything you need to know about the kind of production he is capable of bringing to your team.”

    Brooke Morgan· Sep 4, 2026
Christian McCaffrey
  • “Year 2 post-tibia fracture: • 4.1 YPC → 3.5 YPC • 3.04 yards after contact per attempt → 2.78 • 0.217 missed tackles forced per attempt → 0.161 Christian McCaffrey does not appear to have the same league-winning upside as last season (18.5 FPG) - 1 top-5 weekly RB finish through four games, compared to 11 in 17 games last season.”

    The FF Newsletter· Oct 8, 2026
  • “Christian McCaffrey finished as RB3 despite only recording 23 rushing yards, thanks to two rushing TDs.”

    Jordan Pullett· Sep 25, 2026
  • “Christian McCaffrey – 8 targets, 5 rec McCaffrey has hit triple-digit targets in five different seasons. He’s arguably the best pass-catching RB in NFL history. If CMC is healthy, he is in your lineup, but it is nice to see that he is still very involved in the passing game.”

    Aaron Larson· Sep 15, 2026
See 10 more
  • “If we could turn injuries off like in the Madden video game, McCaffrey would be the clear-cut 1.01 pick in every non-superflex draft.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Sep 5, 2026
  • “Andrew Erickson’s Draft Landmines of 2026 Christian McCaffrey (RB – SF) Christian McCaffrey led the NFL with 413 touches in 2025 and reached 450 when including the playoffs.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Sep 4, 2026
  • “Going as the RB3, roughly the eighth overall pick, McCaffrey is coming off a season that led all players in total touches. Historically, that’s a dangerous signal: over the last 13 years, only one running back who saw 400-plus touches in a season finished as a top-five back the next year, and running backs age 27 or older who led the league in touches have never finished top five the following season across six such occurrences.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Aug 23, 2026
  • “He’s entering his age-30 season with a lot of miles on the tread. McCaffrey is absolutely capable of smashing, but he could also miss some games. Since 2020, he’s missed half the season or more three times.”

    Kyle Zeigler· Aug 18, 2026
  • “In a full PPR format, CMC represents one of the few RBs in the league who really benefits from the extra bump per reception. McCaffrey had a whopping 102 receptions last season and could very well be one of the main receiving weapons in San Francisco again in 2026.”

    Kurt Mullen· Aug 14, 2026
  • “Christian McCaffrey | RB, San Francisco 49ers Heading into what will be his 10th season in the NFL, Christian McCaffrey is coming off another season of monstrous volume.”

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 11, 2026
  • “McCaffrey is coming off a season where he touched the ball 400+ times and finished all but one week of the season as a top-24 RB. The biggest “if” with CMC is his health, but when he is on the field, he is a fantasy league winner.”

    Kurt Mullen· Aug 7, 2026
  • “2 Something to note is that while Christian McCaffrey did not reach the total rushing attempts needed to hit this criterion last season, he did have 311 carries, along with 102 receptions, putting his total workload at a similar number.”

    Jordan Pullett· Jul 29, 2026
  • “The last time McCaffrey had over 400 touches in a year, the superstar missed 69.7% of the games over the next two seasons because of injury.”

    Mike Fanelli· Jul 28, 2026
  • “McCaffrey was the RB1 in points per game, scoring 2.5 points more than the RB2. Once again, the 49ers did very little to persuade us that they don’t believe in McCaffrey’s ability to be a workhorse, instead continuing their habit of talking up a later-round dart throw at the position, who’ll likely struggle to see any involvement.”

    Tom Strachan· Jul 27, 2026

Who scores most this week?

Choose your top 3 from upcoming games.

Tap players in order to build your rankings.

Open full game ↗
Past weeks
Draft history and ADP
ADP 1.9
Jahmyr Gibbs
RB · DET · RB1
ADP 4.1
Christian McCaffrey
RB · SF · RB3
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
89% would rather draft Gibbs over McCaffrey
89%Gibbs
11%McCaffrey
Based on 977 comparison results