Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

DeVonta Smith
vs Malik Nabers

2026 · Week 5 · Half-PPR

Out
DeVonta Smith
WR · PHI
Malik Nabers
WR · NYG

The crowd’s lean

Week 5

No weekly comparisons recorded for this pair.

This week

WEEK 5

Smith

at JAX

Oct 11 · 9:30 AM ET

Out

Nabers

at WAS

Oct 11 · 1:00 PM ET

—

Live

11.7

Projected

Half-PPR
points

—Sleeper projection11.7

This week's comparison isn't ready yet. Check back later.

2026 season, per game

SmithNabers
13.0Fantasy pts9.0
3Games4
9.0Targets6.5
6.3Receptions4.5
78Receiving yds52
—Touchdowns—
SmithNabers
9.6Fantasy pts12.0
17Games4
6.6Targets8.8
4.5Receptions4.5
59Receiving yds68
0.2Touchdowns0.5
Full game log & past seasons +
DeVonta Smith
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
—
6.8
WR44
6
3
53
—
2
—
22.7
WR6
13
10
117
1
3
—
9.5
WR38
8
6
65
—
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
DAL
3.1
WR79
3
3
16
—
2
KC
7.3
WR53
6
4
53
—
3
LAR
16.0
WR12
9
8
60
1
4
TB
3.9
WR67
2
2
29
—
5
DEN
15.4
WR14
10
8
114
—
6
NYG
6.9
WR38
5
4
49
—
7
MIN
28.8
WR2
11
9
183
1
8
NYG
11.4
WR21
9
6
84
—
9
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
10
GB
14.9
WR17
7
4
69
1
11
DET
1.3
WR95
5
1
8
—
12
DAL
11.9
WR20
11
6
89
—
13
CHI
7.3
WR39
8
5
48
—
14
LAC
5.7
WR41
8
4
37
—
15
LV
6.0
WR53
2
2
50
—
16
WAS
13.2
WR18
8
6
42
1
17
BUF
3.5
WR73
5
2
25
—
18
WAS
6.7
WR33
4
3
52
—
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
GB
11.9
WR21
8
7
84
—
2
ATL
17.1
WR14
10
7
76
1
3
NO
11.4
WR30
10
7
79
—
4
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
CLE
13.9
WR20
4
3
64
1
7
NYG
0.3
WR103
2
1
-2
—
8
CIN
17.5
WR8
7
6
85
1
9
JAX
16.7
WR11
6
4
87
1
10
DAL
2.4
WR74
3
2
14
—
11
WAS
4.9
WR55
6
4
29
—
12
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
13
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
14
CAR
11.7
WR27
6
4
37
1
15
PIT
22.5
WR6
12
11
109
1
16
WAS
8.1
WR48
8
6
51
—
17
DAL
27.0
WR3
7
6
120
2
Malik Nabers
2026 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
—
9.9
WR28
9
6
69
—
2
—
0.6
WR116
4
1
1
—
3
—
5.1
WR66
6
5
26
—
4
—
20.2
WR10
7
6
112
1
Earlier seasons (2025, 2024)
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
WAS
9.6
WR28
12
5
71
—
2
DAL
33.2
WR2
13
9
167
2
3
KC
2.3
WR88
7
2
13
—
4
LAC
3.0
WR77
3
2
20
—
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
MIN
9.1
WR32
7
5
66
—
2
WAS
23.7
WR3
18
10
127
1
3
CLE
24.2
WR3
12
8
78
2
4
DAL
17.1
WR12
15
12
115
—
5
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
7
PHI
6.1
WR43
8
4
41
—
8
PIT
10.6
WR38
13
7
71
—
9
WAS
10.4
WR29
11
9
59
—
10
CAR
7.8
WR30
10
6
50
—
11
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
12
TB
9.4
WR26
9
6
64
—
13
DAL
11.3
WR28
13
8
69
—
14
NO
12.4
WR25
10
5
79
—
15
BAL
19.2
WR10
14
10
82
1
16
ATL
10.3
WR32
14
7
68
—
17
IND
32.6
WR2
8
7
171
2
18
PHI
14.9
WR15
8
5
64
1

Expert takes

DeVonta Smith
  • “WR Quick Hitters DeVonta Smith | WR, Philadelphia Eagles (OUT) – DeVonta Smith is still out with a hamstring strain. He had a hamstring issue in the preseason and played well early in the regular season before this setback. He’s been at practice, and while he’s been unable to participate, he has been running, jogging, and stretching with the team.”

    Jonathan Lange· Oct 10, 2026
  • “Jalen Hurts is the Ballers’ consensus QB19, while Saquon Barkley and DeVonta Smith will miss this week.”

    Jordan Pullett· Oct 10, 2026
  • ““ DeVonta Smith is a scary play this week. Philadelphia’s passing volume remains underwhelming, and Trent McDuffie will likely be matched up with him for much of the game. McDuffie has only allowed three receptions for 61 yards and no touchdowns this year, so I’d be a bit surprised if DeVonta lives up to his WR10 price tag this week.” – Jim Moorman ( Dynasty Football Factory )”

    FantasyPros Staff· Oct 1, 2026
See 11 more
  • “Smith could remain sidelined another week or two, and with Saquon Barkley and Tank Bigsby injured, the Eagles are in danger of imploding. Add in Lane Johnson’s retirement and Jalen Hurts ‘ inability to feed his receivers, and I just don’t see a path where DeVonta can pay off at these prices. I’d be willing to swap DeVonta for Coker straight up, but you can likely get a FLEX-worthy play on top of Coker, based on market prices.” – Jim Moorman ( Dynasty Football Factory )”

    FantasyPros Staff· Oct 8, 2026
  • “The passing volume simply isn’t there with Jalen Hurts under center; Smith would need to post some otherworldly per-route efficiency numbers to even sniff a top-12 wide receiver finish this season. Count me out.”

    Jim Moorman· Oct 6, 2026
  • “Over two games this season, Smith has 38.9% of the team's targets against Cover 1, averaging 2.74 yards per route run.”

    Rich Hribar· Sep 24, 2026
  • “DeVonta Smith ‘ s 36% target share is the 5th highest among all WRs so far.”

    Kyle Borgognoni· Sep 21, 2026
  • “DeVonta Smith was expected to shift into a feature role following Philadelphia’s decision to deal A.J. Brown to New England, but it appears that the Eagles missed the memo. Quarterback Jalen Hurts hardly threw passes all afternoon, completing just 14 passes for 203 yards, primarily deep strikes to Dallas Goedert and Dontayvion Wicks .”

    Evan Tarracciano· Sep 14, 2026
  • “Smith ranks as Andy’s WR9 in a matchup against the Commanders, who ranked last in yards allowed per game last season.”

    Jordan Pullett· Sep 12, 2026
  • “the Bengals hints that DeVonta Smith will play significant slot snaps, too, which probably bodes well for Smith’s fantasy value.”

    Pat Fitzmaurice· Aug 31, 2026
  • “01 | DeVonta Smith | WR, Philadelphia Eagles DeVonta Smith ‘s Athletic Profile Last season, DeVonta Smith finished just outside of WR2 range with an underwhelming 11.9 FPPG.”

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 29, 2026
  • “Ladd McConkey and DeVonta Smith were also considered. 4.11: Jaylen Waddle (WR – DEN) Jaylen Waddle is being overlooked as he enters his first year with the Broncos.”

    Kurt Blakeway· Aug 25, 2026
  • “However, Smith was outstanding when seeing enough volume, averaging 19.3 fantasy points per game in the seven contests where he had seven or more targets, scoring 20 or more in nearly a third of those outings.”

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 16, 2026
  • “Smith is a perfect WR pairing with Nabers, bringing a player fantasy managers should feel good about not only being the top target on their team, but one who has proven he can carry the load as a top-12 WR for fantasy.”

    Kurt Mullen· Aug 7, 2026
Malik Nabers
  • “So far this season, according to the Fantasy Points Data Suite, Nabers has a 25.6% target share on all routes run and averages 0.45 fantasy points per route. This week he is up against Amik Robertson . I do feel bad for name-checking Robertson every week in this column .”

    Adam Murfet· Oct 8, 2026
  • “Nabers is coming off a good game, opening the door to selling him high. Daniel Jones has played poorly this year, and Alec Pierce ‘s absence is concerning for Jonathan Taylor ‘s outlook. In 17 games with Pierce since 2025, Taylor has recorded 96.1 rushing yards per game, 4.9 yards per carry and 20.58 half-PPR points per game.”

    Josh Shepardson· Oct 10, 2026
  • “He is coming off his best game of the season, but let’s be honest with ourselves here: going into the week, you would have loved to be fielding offers for Nabers with the situation the Giants’ offense was facing and the different injuries Nabers was dealing with as well. Now he has his big game, and lets not revert back to holding again, lets take our blessing and sell, sell, sell. I would look to grab someone like a Tetairoa McMillan who just had a monster game, but could easily fool owners into a sell-high situation himself.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Oct 8, 2026
See 10 more
  • “Here’s the thing: Malik Nabers is not back to full health yet. He’s near the bottom of the league in separation score this season and is sitting behind Isaiah Likely in target share. With every passing week, Nabers should be inching closer to his old self.”

    Jim Moorman· Oct 6, 2026
  • “As a result of Winston getting back to slinging it, Malik Nabers had six receptions for 112 yards and a touchdown on seven targets, and Isaiah Likely had seven receptions for 66 scoreless yards on 12 targets. Winston’s showing provides gamers with hope for Nabers and Likely. That said, it may be best to use this as a selling window for Nabers.”

    Josh Shepardson· Oct 5, 2026
  • “Winston was trying to keep it simple by going to his first read at the seventh-highest rate, and even though Malik Nabers was the first read on 37% of plays, it counted for nothing because of the poor weather and the crowded area the ball was thrown into. We have to face the fact that this could be another lost season for Nabers, who hasn’t yet reached 10 half-PPR points in any game. The Cardinals’ pass defense ranks 30th in EPA allowed and has given up the 12th-most schedule-adjusted fantasy points to wide receivers.”

    Tom Strachan· Sep 30, 2026
  • “If you drafted Nabers expecting a weekly WR1, there is plenty of reason to panic. I’m not selling him for scraps, and I’m not outright dropping him, but he’s fallen into risky FLEX territory. On the plus side, the Giants have three favorable matchups coming up.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Sep 29, 2026
  • “Nabers was targeted on four occasions in the loss , missing a handful of snaps due to – what later turned out to be – a dislocated shoulder…and this is what concerns me way more than who happens to be throwing the former first-round pick the ball for the rest of the year. With Dart out, you could be forgiven for proclaiming this an already lost season for John Harbaugh’s men – so would it be crazy to suggest they may just shut down their star WR to save any more damage being done for little to no gain?”

    PaulMarnie· Sep 26, 2026
  • “Stack Idea: Dart + Nabers + Kyren + Mevis Malik Nabers $13,500 Nabers is my lower-owned CPT alternative, as I currently have him at just under 10%. He caught six passes for 69 yards in his return last week, and his projected CPT ownership is less than half Dart’s. I want some lineups where the Giants’ biggest receiving performance belongs to Nabers, with Dart collecting the passing points in FLEX.”

    Chris Cash· Sep 21, 2026
  • “Nabers ran a route on 24 of those 36 snaps and quickly commanded nine targets.”

    Nate Henry· Sep 15, 2026
  • “Malik Nabers (WR – NYG) Going as the WR11, around the 27th overall pick, Nabers has shown real positive injury progression, moving out of the no-contact jersey and into full team drills.”

    FantasyPros Staff· Aug 28, 2026
  • “Malik Nabers completely avoided the PUP list this offseason and has been trending towards starting the season as close to completely healthy as anyone could have hoped for. Nabers is still a potential value at his current ECR and ADP, as it was at this time just a year ago, when he was a popular first round draft target.”

    Raju Byfield· Aug 23, 2026
  • “At the start of the offseason, this was a no-brainer selection for “riskiest player to draft.” After all, Malik Nabers could barely hobble to first base in a friendly kickball game.”

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 21, 2026

Who scores most this week?

Choose your top 3 from upcoming games.

Tap players in order to build your rankings.

Open full game ↗
Past weeks
Draft history and ADP
ADP 33.3
Out
DeVonta Smith
WR · PHI · WR14
ADP 27.3
Malik Nabers
WR · NYG · WR11
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
72.7% would rather draft Nabers over Smith
27.3%Smith
72.7%Nabers
Based on 55 comparison results