Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

DeVonta Smith vs Malik Nabers

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Aug 13, 2026

ADP 39
Questionable
DeVonta Smith
WR · PHI · WR17
ADP 30
Questionable
Malik Nabers
WR · NYG · WR12
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
76.9% would rather draft Nabers over Smith
23.1%Smith
76.9%Nabers
Based on 26 comparison results

Should you draft DeVonta Smith or Malik Nabers?

Last season — 2025, per game

SmithWR20 finish
2025
NabersWR93 finish
9.6Fantasy pts12.0
17Games4
6.6Targets8.8
4.5Rec4.5
59Rec yds68
0.2TD0.5
Full game log & past seasons
DeVonta Smith
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
DAL
3.1
WR79
3
3
16
0
2
KC
7.3
WR53
6
4
53
0
3
LAR
16.0
WR12
9
8
60
1
4
TB
3.9
WR67
2
2
29
0
5
DEN
15.4
WR14
10
8
114
0
6
NYG
6.9
WR38
5
4
49
0
7
MIN
28.8
WR2
11
9
183
1
8
NYG
11.4
WR21
9
6
84
0
9
10
GB
14.9
WR17
7
4
69
1
11
DET
1.3
WR95
5
1
8
0
12
DAL
11.9
WR20
11
6
89
0
13
CHI
7.3
WR39
8
5
48
0
14
LAC
5.7
WR41
8
4
37
0
15
LV
6.0
WR53
2
2
50
0
16
WAS
13.2
WR18
8
6
42
1
17
BUF
3.5
WR73
5
2
25
0
18
WAS
6.7
WR33
4
3
52
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
GB
11.9
WR21
8
7
84
0
2
ATL
17.1
WR14
10
7
76
1
3
NO
11.4
WR30
10
7
79
0
4
5
6
CLE
13.9
WR20
4
3
64
1
7
NYG
0.3
WR103
2
1
-2
0
8
CIN
17.5
WR8
7
6
85
1
9
JAX
16.7
WR11
6
4
87
1
10
DAL
2.4
WR74
3
2
14
0
11
WAS
4.9
WR55
6
4
29
0
12
13
14
CAR
11.7
WR27
6
4
37
1
15
PIT
22.5
WR6
12
11
109
1
16
WAS
8.1
WR48
8
6
51
0
17
DAL
27.0
WR3
7
6
120
2
Malik Nabers
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
WAS
9.6
WR28
12
5
71
0
2
DAL
33.2
WR2
13
9
167
2
3
KC
2.3
WR88
7
2
13
0
4
LAC
3.0
WR77
3
2
20
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
MIN
9.1
WR32
7
5
66
0
2
WAS
23.7
WR3
18
10
127
1
3
CLE
24.2
WR3
12
8
78
2
4
DAL
17.1
WR12
15
12
115
0
5
6
7
PHI
6.1
WR43
8
4
41
0
8
PIT
10.6
WR38
13
7
71
0
9
WAS
10.4
WR29
11
9
59
0
10
CAR
7.8
WR30
10
6
50
0
11
12
TB
9.4
WR26
9
6
64
0
13
DAL
11.3
WR28
13
8
69
0
14
NO
12.4
WR25
10
5
79
0
15
BAL
19.2
WR10
14
10
82
1
16
ATL
10.3
WR32
14
7
68
0
17
IND
32.6
WR2
8
7
171
2
18
PHI
14.9
WR15
8
5
64
1

Latest takes

DeVonta Smith
  • Honorable mention: DeVonta Smith and Luther Burden .” – Mark Ringo ( Sleepers and Busts ) Garrett Wilson (WR – NYJ) “ Garrett Wilson is an elite talent stuck on a team lacking elite quarterback play.

  • Advice: Moore is clearly behind DeVonta Smith , Dontaviyon Wicks, Darius Cooper, Makai Lemon , and Marquise Brown .

    Raju Byfield· Aug 10
  • DeVonta Smith (WR – PHI) Going as the WR12, 30th overall, one analyst has him as his WR10 and draws a direct comparison to a receiver who broke out immediately after a more famous teammate left the team last year.

See 12 more
  • Smith is a perfect WR pairing with Nabers, bringing a player fantasy managers should feel good about not only being the top target on their team, but one who has proven he can carry the load as a top-12 WR for fantasy.

    Kurt Mullen· Aug 7
  • 83.9% outside, 78.5% on-ball DeVonta Smith ’s 2025 Reception Perception profile:

  • When one of Brown or DeVonta Smith has missed time in the past, Goedert has stepped up as the second option

  • Round 5: DeVonta Smith (WR – PHI) Dallas Cowboys running back Javonte Williams was staring me in the face, but with a FLEX spot still available in a PPR league, I couldn’t pass up DeVonta Smith .

  • DeVonta Smith is a terrific receiver, but it might be a mistake to assume that Smith’s 2026 numbers will dwarf those of Lemon, the 20th overall pick in this year’s draft.

  • WR DeVonta Smith will move into the WR1 role on the Eagles and in fantasy. When A.J. Brown has missed games in the past, he steps up.

    Maggie Thraen· Jul 25
  • DeVonta Smith (PHI) : ADP 26.5 | WR12 The worst-kept secret in the NFL was the A.J. Brown trade. Smith has taken over as the Eagles’ No. 1 wide receiver with Brown in New England. Last season, he finished as the WR20, averaging 11.9 PPR fantasy points per game.

    Mike Fanelli· Jul 22
  • Last season, DeVonta Smith (like the rest of the Eagles’ offense) failed to live up to expectations. It was the former Heisman Trophy winner’s worst statistical season since his rookie year, way back in 2021. This year, the Eagles have made some changes.

    Kyle Lesti· Jul 20
  • In 21 games without Brown, Smith has over 1,200 yards and six touchdowns with almost seven targets per game. Now the clear No. 1 WR in Philly, his cost on Fantrax is just far too low.

    Ryan Kirksey· Jul 7
  • He also pointed to anticipated schematic changes that could create more play-action and pre-snap motion, potentially increasing Smith's efficiency without requiring a dramatic spike in volume.

  • Jake Ciely believes Devonta Smith continues to be undervalued. Smith has already demonstrated that he can produce WR1 numbers whenever he's asked to handle a featured role. Even with other weapons in the offense, Ciely expects Philadelphia's passing attack to remain heavily concentrated, giving Smith another opportunity to outperform his draft position.

  • Smith has averaged over 1,000 receiving yards per season despite serving as a complementary piece to Brown. He is wired for big moments and big roles, and feels more than ready to become the focal point of the Eagles' passing game. He will almost certainly dominate targets in 2026 as long as he stays healthy.

    FFToday· Jul 2
Malik Nabers
  • If he can string together a healthy season, we could be looking at a low-end WR1 on a perennially potent offense.” – Ellis Johnson ( FantasyPros ) Malik Nabers (WR – NYG) “ Malik Nabers is my pick.

  • There is plenty of uncertainty around Nabers and whether or not he will be his usual explosive self to start the season, but getting a WR of this caliber in the third round is the type of pick that can really make a difference down the stretch of the season if he is back to 100%.

    Kurt Mullen· Aug 7
  • I’m going to piggyback on my running back health statement above and avoid Malik Nabers at receiver.

See 12 more
  • Only SEC WR besides Malik Nabers with 30+ missed tackles forced on receptions in a season over the past 5 years

  • This should lock him into the second option behind Malik Nabers

  • Add in the fact that Malik Nabers is recovering from a significant knee injury, and you can see why Dart is a pass.

  • Malik Nabers (WR – NYG): Down 4 spots to No. 44 A slow, steady bleed that’s now the longest-running faller trend over the last few weeks. Nabers has slipped roughly 14 spots since we first flagged him in late June for missing mandatory minicamp during a lengthy ACL and meniscus rehab.

  • Malik Nabers, CeeDee Lamb, and Justin Jefferson all have similar LTV scores in the same range as Love’s.

  • This dip will only increase when Malik Nabers heads to the physically unable to perform (PUP) list at the start of training camp. Latest reports suggest it could be Week 5 or 6 before Nabers is back to full health.

    Tom Strachan· Jul 20
  • Nabers could miss the start of the year and might not be 100% until 2027, making him a massive risk to draft as a top-12 wide receiver.

    Mike Fanelli· Jul 20
  • The Giants know what they have in a healthy Nabers, and they know what they have in his absence. If available, he'll be a main focus and favorite target for second-year quarterback Jaxson Dart, and if he's not, then he won't.

    Ely Allen· Jul 13
  • Malik Nabers and Tucker Kraft finish outside WR50 and TE20, respectively. Nabers is still way too expensive at WR 17, but he's coming off reconstructive knee surgery, and even Nabers admitted to ESPN's Adam Schefter that week one sounds "a little ambitious."

  • Is Malik Nabers worth your entire FAAB budget in a chopped league? Unfortunately, Malik Nabers suffered a season-ending injury just four days after this post.

  • Malik Nabers is targeting a Week 1 return after undergoing a cleanup procedure on the knee he previously had surgery on for a torn ACL and a full meniscus repair.

  • After an electric rookie season, Nabers' sophomore season was cut short with a severe ACL tear. Although Nabers should be close to fully back, he has had some setbacks and a cleanup procedure this offseason.

    Ellis Johnson· Jun 29