Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Caleb Williams vs Kyle Pitts

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Sep 9, 2026

ADP 74.1
Caleb Williams
QB · CHI · QB7
ADP 71.4
Kyle Pitts
TE · ATL · TE7
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
68% would rather draft Williams over Pitts
68%Williams
32%Pitts
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Caleb Williams or Kyle Pitts?

Last season — 2025, per game

Williams17 games
2025
Pitts17 games
19.1Fantasy pts9.8
17Games17
232Pass yds0
1.6Pass TD0.0
0.4INT0.0
4.5Carries0.0
23Rush yds0
5.0Yds/carry0.0
0.1Targets6.9
0.1Rec5.2
1Rec yds55
0.2TD0.3
Full game log & past seasons
Caleb Williams
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTCMPYDTDINTRuYDRuTD
1
MIN
24.2
QB9
35
21
210
1
0
58
1
2
DET
18.0
QB20
30
19
207
2
1
27
0
3
DAL
29.1
QB1
28
19
298
4
0
12
0
4
LV
12.8
QB24
37
22
212
1
1
13
0
5
6
WAS
19.9
QB10
29
17
252
1
0
-2
1
7
NO
5.7
QB27
26
15
172
0
1
-2
0
8
BAL
12.8
QB20
38
25
285
0
1
24
0
9
CIN
37.7
QB1
34
20
280
3
0
53
0
10
NYG
25.1
QB4
36
20
220
1
0
63
1
11
MIN
10.3
QB22
32
16
193
0
0
26
0
12
PIT
21.7
QB6
35
19
239
3
0
21
0
13
PHI
10.5
QB25
36
17
154
1
1
13
0
14
GB
15.9
QB16
35
19
186
2
1
15
0
15
CLE
19.0
QB15
28
17
242
2
0
13
0
16
GB
21.0
QB9
34
19
250
2
0
30
0
17
SF
23.0
QB7
42
25
330
2
0
18
0
18
DET
17.6
QB10
33
20
212
2
1
1
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTCMPYDTDINTRuYDRuTD
1
TEN
7.2
QB31
29
14
93
0
0
15
0
2
HOU
9.4
QB29
37
23
174
0
2
44
0
3
IND
19.3
QB14
52
33
363
2
2
8
0
4
LAR
11.5
QB21
23
17
157
1
0
12
0
5
CAR
23.6
QB6
29
20
304
2
0
34
0
6
JAX
29.6
QB1
29
23
226
4
1
56
0
7
BYE
8
WAS
9.9
QB28
24
10
131
0
0
47
0
9
ARI
9.2
QB28
41
22
217
0
0
5
0
10
NE
6.3
QB26
30
16
120
0
0
15
0
11
GB
16.2
QB21
31
23
231
0
0
70
0
12
MIN
26.9
QB4
47
32
340
2
0
33
0
13
DET
26.1
QB5
39
20
256
3
0
39
0
14
SF
14.1
QB18
23
17
134
2
0
27
0
15
MIN
9.9
QB23
31
18
191
1
0
3
0
16
DET
22.8
QB9
40
26
334
2
0
34
0
17
SEA
7.6
QB32
28
16
122
0
1
37
0
18
GB
10.9
QB24
29
21
148
1
0
10
0
Kyle Pitts
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
TB
9.4
TE12
8
7
59
0
2
MIN
5.7
TE19
5
4
37
0
3
CAR
5.9
TE21
6
4
39
0
4
WAS
15.5
TE4
5
5
70
1
5
BYE
6
BUF
3.3
TE36
4
3
18
0
7
SF
9.7
TE15
10
7
62
0
8
MIA
10.4
TE9
9
9
59
0
9
NE
5.8
TE25
7
4
38
0
10
IND
4.8
TE24
5
2
38
0
11
CAR
2.4
TE39
3
2
14
0
12
NO
3.5
TE31
5
2
25
0
13
NYJ
11.7
TE6
8
7
82
0
14
SEA
12.0
TE7
10
6
90
0
15
TB
40.1
TE1
12
11
166
3
16
ARI
15.2
TE3
9
7
57
1
17
LAR
2.6
TE38
3
2
16
0
18
NO
8.8
TE12
9
6
58
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
PIT
10.1
TE3
3
3
26
1
2
PHI
3.5
TE23
4
3
20
0
3
KC
6.9
TE9
5
2
59
0
4
NO
0.0
TE72
3
0
0
0
5
TB
12.3
TE6
8
7
88
0
6
CAR
8.5
TE13
5
3
70
0
7
SEA
10.0
TE11
9
7
65
0
8
TB
23.1
TE2
5
4
91
2
9
DAL
1.6
TE40
1
1
11
0
10
NO
7.5
TE13
6
4
55
0
11
DEN
1.4
TE42
3
1
9
0
12
13
LAC
0.0
TE78
2
0
0
0
14
MIN
1.9
TE37
6
1
14
0
15
LV
4.8
TE23
4
4
28
0
16
NYG
1.2
TE45
2
1
7
0
17
WAS
12.4
TE9
5
4
44
1
18
CAR
2.5
TE41
3
2
15
0

Latest takes

Caleb Williams
  • NO RB17 20 60 43 7 -8 44 4 Drake Maye NE QB3 27 87 44 14 8 45 4 D’Andre Swift CHI RB18 27 66 48 8 -1 46 4 Terry McLaurin WAS WR22 35 70 49 7 9 47 4 Luther Burden III CHI WR23 27 75 49 10 7 48 4 Davante Adams LAR WR24 36 69 50 7 9 49 4 Joe Burrow CIN QB4 27 85 50 14 4 50 4 Jameson Williams DET WR25 32 83 52 9 10 51 4 Bucky Irving TB RB19 33 82 53 8 -4 52 4 Tyler Warren IND TE4 22 78 54 10 -1 53 4 Cam Skattebo NYG RB20 39 77 54 7 -16 54 4 David Montgomery HOU RB21 34 70 54 7 -4 55 4 DJ Moore BUF WR26 21 92 55 12 -7 56 4 Quinshon Judkins CLE RB22 32 83 55 8 -10 57 4 Christian Watson GB WR27 40 87 56 10 7 58 4 Rome Odunze CHI WR28 43 89 59 9 4 59 4 Bhayshul Tuten JAC RB23 37 82 60 9 -1 60 4 Jadarian Price SEA RB24 35 79 60 9 -4 61 4 Jayden Daniels WAS QB5 34 100 60 14 2 62 4 Mike Evans SF WR29 35 108 60 12 4 63 4 Jalen Hurts PHI QB6 29 97 61 13 -2 64 4 Parker Washington JAC WR30 32 138 64 15 3 65 5 TreVeyon Henderson NE RB25 42 100 67 10 -6 66 5 Caleb Williams CHI QB7 36 98 68 13 6 67 5 Rhamondre Stevenson NE RB26 51 98 69 10 2 68 5 Tucker Kraft GB TE5 34 110 70 13 -3 69 5 Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • All of these identifiers tell us who Caleb Williams is and who other QBs are that we can group him with.

  • Williams stepping into a record-breaking environment completely deletes his market floor. Johnson’s scheme would demand hyper-efficiency, pushing Williams into a historic TD tier and vaulting him past expensive, established signal-callers straight into elite top-3 overall fantasy status.

    Nate Henry· Aug 28
See 12 more
  • Andy gets his guy in Caleb Williams at QB in hopes that he can take another step forward going into year three. He jumped from 15 PPG as a rookie to 18.6 last year under Ben Johnson, good enough for a QB7 finish.

    Parker Hagen· Aug 27
  • Caleb Williams (QB – CHI) Last season proved that Caleb Williams could hold his own under new head coach Ben Johnson. He led Chicago to the NFC North title and a playoff win.

  • Caleb Williams (QB – CHI) Williams graded out as a mild negative-regression case, and the notes explain why the risk is real: his QB7 fantasy finish badly outran his passing, as he ranked near the bottom of the league in accuracy and catchable-target rate. His fantasy value is propped up by rushing, so if that production dips even slightly, his stock slides.

  • Another important component in Loveland’s ascent is Caleb Williams . Williams registered an off-target throw on 15.9% of his passes targeted at the rookie tight end last season. Entering his third season in the NFL and second season with Johnson, Williams appears more comfortable running the offense than a year ago.

    Curtis Hirsch· Aug 18
  • Caleb Williams took a big step forward in 2025 under new Bears head coach and playcaller Ben Johnson , finishing QB6 in fantasy scoring. Williams threw for a franchise-record 3,942 yards.

  • Odunze could very well be the WR1 in this offense, and now with Burden sidelined with a groin injury, it will allow Rome to further establish a deeper connection with Caleb Williams .

  • Caleb Williams was once considered a “can’t-miss” quarterback prospect. After a disappointing rookie season, Caleb showed flashes of brilliance in Year 1 with Ben Johnson.

  • Caleb Williams, 2025 (+0.27) Stefon Diggs heads to D.C

  • I can’t say that I dislike Caleb Williams as a fantasy asset; I just don’t think that he should go a full round ahead of Dak Prescott and sixteen picks before Trevor Lawrence.

    Jeff Krisko· Jul 24
  • Williams finished last year as the QB5, averaging 1.6 passing touchdowns and 18.7 fantasy points per game. However, he was the QB7 on a points-per-game basis, averaging less than Matthew Stafford (20.6) and Brock Purdy (19.7).

    Mike Fanelli· Jul 17
  • The community is so busy mourning Moore's departure that they completely ignore the elite talent left behind in Rome Odunze, Luther Burden III and Colston Loveland. To cap it off, Williams gets a five-star schedule to exploit this season.

  • Caleb Williams is coming off a sophomore leap, finishing as the QB6 with 323.3 fantasy points. Despite that elite production, the fantasy community is treating his breakout like a fluke. Williams' value remains secure because he provides a safe floor and a high ceiling with his rushing ability and off-script playmaking.

Kyle Pitts
  • The Falcons don’t have a lot of firepower at wide receiver beyond Drake London , so Kyle Pitts could very well be Atlanta’s No.

  • Players like Jaylen Warren , Terry McLaurin , Rico Dowdle , Rashee Rice , Jameson Williams , Emeka Egbuka , Quentin Johnston , and Kyle Pitts can all become interesting depending on where they are still available in your draft.

  • Cousins was starting for Atlanta in Week 15 last season when Kyle Pitts caught 11 passes for 166 yards and three touchdowns.

See 12 more
  • TB WR35 53 123 82 13 6 80 5 Jonathon Brooks CAR RB29 54 139 82 17 0 81 5 Rico Dowdle PIT RB30 64 119 82 11 -5 82 5 Sam LaPorta DET TE7 56 130 83 13 -11 83 5 Kyle Pitts Sr.

  • -Pat Fitzmaurice Must-Know Tight End Fantasy Football Stats Kyle Pitts (TE – ATL) Kyle Pitts had a 22.7% target share last season, but it’ll be a bit of a different situation this season.

  • Kyle Pitts (TE – ATL) Kyle Pitts had a 22.7% target share last season, but it’ll be a bit of a different situation this season First, the Falcons will likely have Tua Tagovailoa under center early in the season, and I don’t trust him as a quarterback whatsoever. Further, Pitts led the team in target share because Drake London played just 12 games.

  • It’s easy to identify the top tier of tight ends in fantasy football this season: Brock Bowers Trey McBride Colston Loveland Tyler Warren Kyle Pitts Tucker Kraft But what does the position look like after that top tier? Below are three tight ends you can draft in the later rounds who have the upside to finish in the top five at the position.

    Kurt Blakeway· Aug 25
  • The much-maligned Kyle Pitts is being drafted in the seventh round.

  • Fantasy managers spent years paying for the Kyle Pitts breakout before it happened. Now that it finally did, no one seems interested in paying for it.

  • 10.04: Kyle Pitts (TE – ATL) This seems late for Pitts, but the concerns about the quarterback play in Atlanta are giving his stock a hit. That is a legitimate concern, but it should be noted that Tua Tagovailoa was able to get Mike Gesicki and Jonnu Smith career seasons.

  • There are compelling midrange options such as Sam LaPorta and Kyle Pitts .

  • isn’t exactly encouraging, but Kyle Pitts led the team in target share last season at 22.7%

  • Kyle Pitts (TE – ATL) The Falcons’ quarterback situation with a nicked-up Tua Tagovailoa and an injured Michael Penix Jr

  • Those are all elite numbers, and if Pitts had put up those stats all year, especially the fantasy points per game, he would have been the TE1 for fantasy. The problem is that with Drake London active, Pitts had a 19% target share, 42.2 receiving yards per game, 1.43 yards per route run, a 20.2% first-read share, 0.093 first downs per route run, and 9.6 fantasy points per game. All of those per route metrics were still quite strong, but the fantasy points per game mark would have made Pitts the TE20 last year.

  • Last year, Kyle Pitts had a tale of two seasons. Yes, overall it was a wonderful year as the TE5 in fantasy points per game and easily his best statistical season since his rookie year, but it was wildly different with Drake London in and out of the lineup. Without London, Pitts had a 26.7% target share with 84.4 receiving yards per game, 2.81 yards per route run, a 27.8% first-read share, 0.120 first downs per route run, and 19 fantasy points per game (per Fantasy Points Data).