Fantasy JoesBuild your rankings

Bucky Irving vs Trey McBride

2026 draft comparison · half-PPR

Updated Sep 6, 2026

ADP 47.2
Bucky Irving
RB · TB · RB21
ADP 26.2
Trey McBride
TE · ARI · TE2
VS
The crowd's leanAll time
64% would rather draft McBride over Irving
36%Irving
64%McBride
Based on 25 comparison results

Should you draft Bucky Irving or Trey McBride?

Last season — 2025, per game

Irving10 games
2025
McBride17 games
12.3Fantasy pts14.9
10Games17
17.3Carries0.0
59Rush yds0
3.4Yds/carry0.0
3.5Targets9.9
3.0Rec7.4
28Rec yds73
0.4TD0.6
Full game log & past seasons
Bucky Irving
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
ATL
12.5
RB19
14
37
0
4
4
8
1
2
HOU
15.1
RB14
17
71
0
6
6
50
0
3
NYJ
11.9
RB17
25
66
0
4
4
33
0
4
PHI
23.0
RB9
15
63
0
5
5
102
1
5
6
7
8
9
10
BYE
11
12
13
ARI
15.1
RB14
17
61
1
2
2
20
0
14
NO
15.1
RB12
15
55
0
3
2
26
1
15
ATL
7.6
RB34
16
60
0
3
1
11
0
16
CAR
7.1
RB41
19
71
0
0
0
0
0
17
MIA
5.8
RB35
9
19
0
6
5
14
0
18
CAR
10.3
RB19
26
85
0
2
1
13
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKATTYDTDTGTRECRYDRTD
1
WAS
8.6
RB31
9
62
0
3
2
14
0
2
DET
2.2
RB62
7
22
0
0
0
0
0
3
DEN
9.9
RB24
9
70
0
3
3
14
0
4
PHI
12.0
RB22
10
49
1
2
1
6
0
5
ATL
4.6
RB43
9
44
0
2
2
12
0
6
NO
17.5
RB11
14
81
1
2
2
24
0
7
BAL
15.2
RB17
9
23
1
3
3
54
0
8
ATL
11.9
RB24
9
44
0
7
7
40
0
9
KC
4.9
RB41
7
24
0
3
3
10
0
10
SF
16.2
RB6
13
73
1
3
3
14
0
11
12
NYG
24.2
RB3
12
88
1
6
6
64
0
13
CAR
26.0
RB1
25
152
1
3
3
33
0
14
LV
2.3
RB49
4
3
0
1
1
15
0
15
LAC
12.3
RB17
15
117
0
2
2
-4
0
16
DAL
16.7
RB16
16
68
1
3
3
24
0
17
CAR
21.0
RB5
20
113
0
4
4
77
0
18
NO
15.4
RB9
19
89
1
5
2
-5
0
Trey McBride
2025 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
NO
9.1
TE13
9
6
61
0
2
CAR
10.8
TE5
7
6
78
0
3
SF
12.8
TE6
8
5
43
1
4
SEA
8.7
TE15
11
7
52
0
5
TEN
6.6
TE23
7
5
41
0
6
IND
17.2
TE2
11
8
72
1
7
GB
24.4
TE3
13
10
74
2
8
9
DAL
14.0
TE6
9
5
55
1
10
SEA
23.2
TE1
13
9
127
1
11
SF
22.5
TE1
11
10
115
1
12
JAX
12.4
TE3
10
9
79
0
13
TB
18.2
TE2
9
8
82
1
14
LAR
8.3
TE13
9
5
58
0
15
HOU
31.4
TE2
13
12
134
2
16
ATL
4.7
TE21
8
4
27
0
17
CIN
18.6
TE1
13
10
76
1
18
LAR
10.0
TE8
8
7
65
0
Earlier seasons (2024)
2024 game log
WKOPPFPTSRANKTGTRECYDTD
1
BUF
5.5
TE11
9
5
30
0
2
LAR
15.7
TE2
6
6
67
0
3
DET
4.0
TE25
6
3
25
0
4
5
SF
8.3
TE16
9
6
53
0
6
GB
13.6
TE4
8
8
96
0
7
LAC
7.6
TE17
7
5
51
0
8
MIA
16.9
TE5
11
9
124
0
9
CHI
11.2
TE8
4
3
35
0
10
NYJ
9.1
TE9
5
4
71
0
11
12
SEA
19.3
TE2
15
12
133
0
13
MIN
15.6
TE6
12
12
96
0
14
SEA
10.5
TE7
14
7
70
0
15
NE
13.2
TE3
10
9
87
0
16
CAR
3.5
TE30
4
3
20
0
17
LAR
24.3
TE1
16
12
123
1
18
SF
16.0
TE2
11
7
65
1

Latest takes

Bucky Irving
  • Dobbins , Jacory Croskey-Merritt , Chris Rodriguez WR – AJ Brown , Chris Olave , Luther Burden , Jordyn Tyson , Malik Washington TE – Tucker Kraft Andy’s Team QB – Malik Willis RB – D’Andre Swift , Jadarian Price , Bucky Irving WR – Jaxon Smith-Njigba , Justin Jefferson , Marvin Harrison Jr ., De’Zhaun Stribling , KC Concepcion , Chris Bell TE – Juwan Johnson Draft Board

    Kurt Mullen· Sep 4
  • Pat Fitzmaurice’s Flag Plant Players of 2026 Bucky Irving (RB – TB) It seems like everyone in the fantasy community is fading Bucky Irving , but I’m buying.

  • Bucky Irving had a sophomore season to forget.

See 12 more
  • If Bucky Irving struggles to stay healthy for the second consecutive season, Gainwell could have a career year.

  • NO RB17 20 60 43 7 -8 44 4 Drake Maye NE QB3 27 87 44 14 8 45 4 D’Andre Swift CHI RB18 27 66 48 8 -1 46 4 Terry McLaurin WAS WR22 35 70 49 7 9 47 4 Luther Burden III CHI WR23 27 75 49 10 7 48 4 Davante Adams LAR WR24 36 69 50 7 9 49 4 Joe Burrow CIN QB4 27 85 50 14 4 50 4 Jameson Williams DET WR25 32 83 52 9 10 51 4 Bucky Irving TB RB19 33 82 53 8 -4 52 4 Tyler Warren IND TE4 22 78 54 10 -1 53 4 Cam Skattebo NYG RB20 39 77 54 7 -16 54 4 David Montgomery HOU RB21 34 70 54 7 -4 55 4 DJ Moore BUF WR26 21 92 55 12 -7 56 4 Quinshon Judkins CLE RB22 32 83 55 8 -10 57 4 Christian Watson GB WR27 40 87 56 10 7 58 4 Rome Odunze CHI WR28 43 89 59 9 4 59 4 Bhayshul Tuten JAC RB23 37 82 60 9 -1 60 4 Jadarian Price SEA RB24 35 79 60 9 -4 61 4 Jayden Daniels WAS QB5 34 100 60 14 2 62 4 Mike Evans SF WR29 35 108 60 12 4 63 4 Jalen Hurts PHI QB6 29 97 61 13 -2 64 4 Parker Washington JAC WR30 32 138 64 15 3 65 5 TreVeyon Henderson NE RB25 42 100 67 10 -6 66 5 Caleb Williams CHI QB7 36 98 68 13 6 67 5 Rhamondre Stevenson NE RB26 51 98 69 10 2 68 5 Tucker Kraft GB TE5 34 110 70 13 -3 69 5 Marvin Harrison Jr.

  • But his competence in pass-protection as well as his chops as a receiver out of the backfield made him a valuable piece to the Buccaneers, even after they landed Bucky Irving.

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 31
  • Last year, Swift was the RB15, averaging 14.3 PPR fantasy points per game, a higher average than Bucky Irving (13.8) and Kenneth Walker III (11.3).

    Mike Fanelli· Aug 31
  • 01 | Bucky Irving | RB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers After breaking out late in his rookie season, Bucky Irving didn’t quite live up to the hype in his abbreviated 2025 season. After missing Weeks 5-12, he tried to play through a nagging shoulder injury — one that would require surgery this past February.

    Kyle Lesti· Aug 29
  • There has yet to be a positive report about Bucky Irving this offseason.

    Ellis Johnson· Aug 21
  • Bucky Irving has dealt with a number of injuries in his short career with a foot sprain and a shoulder/ AC joint sprain last year. Rewinding to 2024, he also dealt with hip, back, toe, and hamstring issues.

  • Bucky Irving , who is returning from a foot and shoulder injury that limited him to 588 rushing yards in 2025 after a breakout rookie campaign in 2024.

  • Check out all of DBro’s top fantasy football draft picks to target >> Bucky Irving (TB) It seems as if everyone in the fantasy community is fading Bucky Irving.

  • It’s odd that so many people are forgetting just how good Irving was over a fairly large sample size of games over the second half of his rookie season. Buy the dip.

  • 8 | Diff: +3 Over the last two seasons, with Bucky Irving in town, Rachaad White was a more effective per-touch player, but with Irving out of the lineup last year, he proved again that he can carry the mail (although while being horribly inefficient).

  • Bucky Irving ‘s rookie season was as impressive as they come, considering his draft capital (125th overall).

Trey McBride
  • Brock Bowers , Colston Loveland , and Trey McBride are the obvious examples heading into this season.

  • Trey McBride (TE – ARI) Trey McBride has a top-20 ADP after catching 126 passes for 1,239 yards and 11 touchdowns last season.

  • His 27 end-zone targets were nine more than the next closest pass-catchers ( Trey McBride / George Pickens ).

See 12 more
  • Players to Avoid at 1.12 Fantasy Football Draft Pick Brock Bowers (TE – LV) & Trey McBride (TE – ARI) Whether you prefer Brock Bowers or Trey McBride doesn’t really matter here.

    Tom Strachan· Aug 31
  • Trey McBride (TE – ARI) Whether you prefer Brock Bowers or Trey McBride doesn’t really matter. Neither should be drafted this high. Last season, McBride averaged 18.6 PPR points per game, and Bowers averaged 15.5 in 2024, the better season of his two years in the NFL.

    Tom Strachan· Aug 28
  • Taking a look at the top options from last season, McBride averaged 11.2 fantasy points per game, and Bowers averaged 9.4 points per game.

  • It’s easy to identify the top tier of tight ends in fantasy football this season: Brock Bowers Trey McBride Colston Loveland Tyler Warren Kyle Pitts Tucker Kraft But what does the position look like after that top tier? Below are three tight ends you can draft in the later rounds who have the upside to finish in the top five at the position.

    Kurt Blakeway· Aug 25
  • There are three tight ends guaranteed to land in the first four rounds: Brock Bowers , Trey McBride , and Colston Loveland .

  • Round 3: Colston Loveland (TE – CHI) I thought about Trey McBride in the previous round, but given the extra boost for tight end receptions, I needed to snag a top player at the position.

  • Cardinals TE Trey McBride has become a prolific fantasy scorer.

  • The second round did see the top two TEs go off the board – Brock Bowers at 2.04 and Trey McBride at 2.06. In a full PPR format, the elite TEs could separate themselves even more than usual, with guys like Bowers and McBride as two of the few guys at the position who could lead their team in targets.

    Kurt Mullen· Aug 14
  • In full-PPR formats, running backs and wide receivers split the top 10 in points per game 50/50, while running backs made up 10 of the top 20 spots in those leagues ( Trey McBride was in there as a tight end).

    Rich Hribar· Aug 12
  • Starting WR/WR with Drake London or Nico Collins in round two could let you lean into Zero RB with an elite tight end such as Brock Bowers or Trey McBride .

    Tom Strachan· Aug 11
  • Let’s use last season’s leading TE scorer, Trey McBride , as an example. He scored 315.9 PPR fantasy points last season. In TE-premium, where he gets an extra half-point for each of his 126 receptions, McBride scored 378.9 fantasy points.

  • McBride ran 156 more routes last year than any other tight end. This fact and McBride’s talent fueled plenty of fantasy teams to championships last season. Among 59 qualifying tight ends, McBride was first in target share (25.4%), receiving yards per game (72.9), red zone targets (32), and first-read share (33.8%).